What a great idea for a thread!, we should have more of these, here's my thoughts and ratings,
1 - Slowish, hangs on every note, and stops the flow of the piece, though certainly makes the piano sing beautifully, quite a heavy left hand, and then gets indulgent at the end and starts wallowing in the beauty of the thing, it loses momentum, though still liked it a lot! - verdict = slow 7 [guess - VH].
2 - The start is too quiet, but there's a nice rubato to it, and the middle section is very inventive, there's poetry and virtuosity there, you can feel a warm fire, the ending is very tender, though a bit too long drawn out - verdict = thoughtful 8 [guess - AR].
3 - This is more like it!, almost perfect, the start is very good, nicely paced, there's a lovely virtuosity there, and a wonderful legato, and the left hand adds to the inner voicing, gets the thing flowing, the trills at the end are very endearing - verdict = poetic 9+ [guess - NM].
4 - Nice inner voice, but the whole thing sounds too detached, not involved enough, lacks poetry to a degree, the speeds are suspect too, and gets too quiet towards the end - verdict = detached 7 [guess ??].
5 - A little bit matter of fact at first, and certainly heavy handed, though there's nice drama, and it gets better and better as it goes, the fastest of the five, and there's something to be said for playing it fast, it keeps it flowing, though maybe it lacks a degree of poetry - verdict = flowing 8 [guess - MP].
preference = 3 / 5 / 2 / 4 / 1