Mahlerly Challenged

[Sergeant Rock]

Mitropoulos, Koln, Tahra

I haven't heard that one...I'll check it out. Thanks, Drasko.

Sarge

[greg]

My favorites are Levine/Chicago, Horenstein/LSO and Bernstein/NY Phil (Sony). Horenstein has an incredibly intense, raucous first movement (the recording balance adds to the excitement, emphasizing brass and timpani). Levine's Bimm bamm movement is unique for the dark undercurrents he discovers running through this normally cheerful piece; Marilyn Horne is sensational in both her movements. And Bernstein is Bernstein; no need to elaborate  

That said, I also really enjoy Chailly. He has the greatest Mahler band at his disposal. Haitink is also worth hearing with this orchestra; their intensity in the final pages is unbeatable.

Sarge

I've heard Horenstein is excellent- as for Bernstein, I haven't caught on yet to any of his from my set.

[DavidW]

I've heard Horenstein is excellent- as for Bernstein, I haven't caught on yet to any of his from my set.

Which set?  DG or Sony?  The DG has some fantastic music making in it, but you have to get used to his slow, uber serious approach to the music.

[eyeresist]

Chailly?  Tennstedt!?  Those are mediocre recordings.

A valuable contribution.

[DavidW]

A valuable contribution.

It's amusing that if someone says that something is good, but with no explanation the person is thanked.
However, if someone says that something is bad, but with no explanation the sarcastic quip is sure to come.