Purchases Today

[Wanderer]

[André]

Genuin is a label that features young artists from the top German Conservatories - an endless fount of bright talents. I haven't been disappointed by any of their releases so far.

[Madiel]

Just ordered off Discogs.



The next cab off the rank in the "your price is a bit high but not horrifying and my expectations are shifting" category.

There was a somewhat cheaper copy (but still not cheap) without a slipcase. I went with the slipcase. There was also another Discogs seller that just never bothered replying to messages, anywhere.

[Kalevala]

Just ordered off Discogs....

The next cab off the rank in the "your price is a bit high but not horrifying and my expectations are shifting" category.

Laughing....

So, how many left to go in the already-released category? 

K

p.s.  Had to change things as I wandered into the Forbidden Zone.

[Madiel]

So, how many left to go in the already-released category?

There are 3 that are supposed to be en route (my level of trust for sellers varies but they should all eventually get here), and 7 not yet bought - though that includes the very recent release that shouldn't be too difficult.

I'm still absolutely kicking myself for missing out on 3 second-hand volumes that appeared at a Discogs shop in Rome. If I hadn't completely fumbled a question to them, I could have had a really good deal.

[Kalevala]

There are 3 that are supposed to be en route (my level of trust for sellers varies but they should all eventually get here), and 7 not yet bought - though that includes the very recent release that shouldn't be too difficult.

I'm still absolutely kicking myself for missing out on 3 second-hand volumes that appeared at a Discogs shop in Rome. If I hadn't completely fumbled a question to them, I could have had a really good deal.

Sounds like you're making good progress!  Have you run across any that you really disliked (or didn't click with) overall that you are thinking of either reselling or donating, etc.?

K

[Madiel]

Have you run across any that you really disliked (or didn't click with) overall

Well, yes...

that you are thinking of either reselling or donating, etc.?

...well, no. You're asking somebody with a distinct liking for sets, who decided to strike out and buy over 70 recordings when he had only heard a selection of them, whether he's now considering getting rid of some of them? It doesn't work like that. Frankly, the question seems odd when you've observed what I'm doing.

The only ones I would get rid of are the concerto/voices box set re-releases that look different, if I decide at some point to be especially silly and aim to get the 5/6 discs in each box in their original stand-alone form. With cardboard slipcases otherwise the switch would be unnecessary.

The only discard thus far is that ridiculous free gift that turned out to be an album by a convicted arsonist and murderer. Which, as previously flagged, is now somewhere in the local garbage dump.

[André]

Shocker: I don't have anything by Alkan.



Version for string orchestra. There have been a number of arrangements for different combinations of instruments. I don't know who did this one.



Graffin is one of my favourite violinists.

[Wanderer]

Shocker: I don't have anything by Alkan.

I'm as shocked as you are. 

[ritter]

Shocker: I don't have anything by Alkan.

I'm as shocked as you are.

I have a grand total of one CD of music by Alkan in my collection!

The one who is not represented at all chez ritter  is...Medtner. 

[Wanderer]

I have a grand total of one CD of music by Alkan in my collection!

The one who is not represented at all chez ritter  is...Medtner. 

I'm glad to say that unlike other problems, these two have very easy solutions. 

[ritter]

I'm glad to say that unlike other problems, these two have very easy solutions. 

Where to start with Medtner, if I may ask?

[André]

I have a grand total of one CD of music by Alkan in my collection!

The one who is not represented at all chez ritter  is...Medtner.

You beat me 1-0 for Alkan. I beat you 2-0 for Medtner. 😉

This is what I have and I certainly recommend it as starters:



If you prefer just piano (sans orchestra), there are multiple options to choose from. Chandos seem to have released quite a few discs of his solo piano music.

[Wanderer]

Where to start with Medtner, if I may ask?

The piano sonatas (Hamelin) and the piano concerti (Tozer 1-3, Alexeev 1, Demidenko 2-3) are good places to start. Two pianos: Knight errant (Alexeev/Demidenko). For chamber music, the violin sonatas (especially fond of Mordkovitch in 1-2). Two more favourites of mine: the Second Improvisation and the Sonate-Vocalise.

[ritter]

Thanks, @André and @Wanderer , for the suggestions. I need to explore...

[JBS]

The piano sonatas (Hamelin) and the piano concerti (Tozer 1-3, Alexeev 1, Demidenko 2-3) are good places to start. Two pianos: Knight errant (Alexeev/Demidenko). For chamber music, the violin sonatas (especially fond of Mordkovitch in 1-2). Two more favourites of mine: the Second Improvisation and the Sonate-Vocalise.

Also these two by Hamish Milne


I would suggest going for the Skazki first, but I'm not sure about its availability.

[ritter]

Thanks to you as well, @JBS ! 

[Madiel]

I have 4 discs of Medtner (the Hyperion ones by Milne which are 2 discs each, and the Skazki were hard to find) and 0.5 discs of Alkan.

[AnotherSpin]

So that everyone can feel comfortable, I should say I have no Medtner albums and no Alkan albums. I never had any Medtner, and about twenty years ago I had two or three Alkan recordings by Hamelin, but they have long since gone.

[Kalevala]

Well, yes...

...well, no. You're asking somebody with a distinct liking for sets, who decided to strike out and buy over 70 recordings when he had only heard a selection of them, whether he's now considering getting rid of some of them? It doesn't work like that. Frankly, the question seems odd when you've observed what I'm doing.

The only ones I would get rid of are the concerto/voices box set re-releases that look different, if I decide at some point to be especially silly and aim to get the 5/6 discs in each box in their original stand-alone form. With cardboard slipcases otherwise the switch would be unnecessary.

The only discard thus far is that ridiculous free gift that turned out to be an album by a convicted arsonist and murderer. Which, as previously flagged, is now somewhere in the local garbage dump.

I don't remember you liking sets per se [Sorry, not trying to be rude here, but I do have things going on in my own life too].  I remember you mentioning about hearing/listening to some of the music--I don't recall all of the details.  I do remember you mentioning one CD that you didn't like at least one of the pieces but liked another, so wondered whether or not you were wanting/able to let things go that you didn't like so well....I know, easier said than done; that's all.   

K