Pieces that have blown you away recently

[Jo498]

I think that first movement of Brahms op.111, especially the beginning borders at the "overdone", trying to make a chamber ensemble sound more orchestral than it plausibly can or should. (It hardly ever works and leads to the silly notion that composers would write string quartets or quintets when they or their material wasn't "good enough" for a "real symphony", or that chamber music is like black and white sketching compared to orchestral oil painting or whatever...)
Admittedly, if done well, it is a great effect but it's borderline. I somewhat heretically overall prefer the 1st quintet, partly because I am not overly fond of the "Vienna prater & hungarian gypsies" connotations of the G major work...

[Luke]

The Brahms String Quartets are masterpieces, IMO. Especially the two minor key ones, which I actually think are among his finest and most powerful chamber works (there's a reason Schoenberg took the C minor as example when illustrating the sophistication, intensity and forward-thinking of Brahms' motivic writing and developing variation form). The idea that they are too clogged texturally gets repeated until it is taken for granted but I don't see or hear it. They are just teeming with ideas and a headlong drive. Just my opinion, of course, but I don't think anyone should be steered away from these pieces, they are too good to miss.

[Jo498]

I agree and I also prefer the op.51 (the a minor is my favorite) to the op.67 with its particular brand of Brahmsian neoclassicism. The 3rd movement of the c minor used to be difficult for me and needs IMO attention by the performers otherwise it can get a bit tedious but I love the dramatic sweep of its outer movements.
While I can understand that lyrical and atmospheric pieces like the first violin sonata or the clarinet quintet are easier to appreciate than the 3 quartets I don't think they are particularly thorny and the features that might be difficult for some listeners can be found in other pieces as well.

[OrchestralNut]

Count me in as another big fan of Brahms' string quartets, especially the first one being my personal favourite. I really don't understand the rather "negative" rap these have received in comparison to his other chamber works.

Probably the first string quartet is my top five Brahms' chamber works, along with:

Clarinet/Viola Sonata No. 1
Piano Quartet No. 3
String Sextet No. 1
Clarinet Trio

[OrchestralNut]

That all being said and even though I think Brahms' chamber works are universally great, I struggle with the Piano Quartet No. 2 in A major, Op. 26. That one tries my patience. 

[Maestro267]

While I enjoyed the Brahms string quartets there were other works I'd place over those. Considering the String Quartet is the primary form of chamber music, acquiring a prestige akin to the Symphony's place in orchestral music. So I can see the mixed reaction they get.

[Løvfald]

If only the first movement of the String Quintet no. 2 in G major survived from Brahms' output, it would be enough for me to consider him a great composer. An absolutely remarkable tour-de-force of a movement, full of textural and rhythmic complexity, unbounded energy, and heartfelt melodies. The other movements of the piece are fine, but they have a hard time living up to that magnificent opening movement IMO.

Indeed, I ADORE that work so much; the movements 2-4 seem unbalanced taking into account the length of the 1st mov., but even so I think the Quintet is imbued with some of the most refined music Brahms wrote IMO.

[relm1]

I really enjoy this brief work.

[Brian]

I finally jumped on the bandwagon that has been traveling around GMG for the last few days, and tried Casella's Concerto for Orchestra (the Chandos recording). Wow! It's by far my favorite Casella. Totally incredible. Would love to see this live. And the BBC bass drum has great oomph at the end.

[kyjo]

I finally jumped on the bandwagon that has been traveling around GMG for the last few days, and tried Casella's Concerto for Orchestra (the Chandos recording). Wow! It's by far my favorite Casella. Totally incredible. Would love to see this live. And the BBC bass drum has great oomph at the end.

Oh yes, it's such a great work, isn't it? Two energetic, life-affirming outer movements surrounding a central Passacaglia of great depth and beauty (there's a particularly spine-tingling passage about 4 minutes in). Are you familiar with his 3rd Symphony (Sinfonia)? It's in a very similar vein stylistically, and is equally great in quality IMO.

[Mapman]

Bernstein: Chichester Psalms

The opening is a bit harsh, but the rest of the 1st movement is rhythmic and fun. The 2nd movement has an interesting structure: 2 psalms in contrasting styles which are then superimposed. The third movement is incredibly beautiful (and mostly in 5). Bernstein's music continues to impress me. (I think my favorite Bernstein works so far are Symphony #2 and Symphonic Dances from West Side Story.)

[Mapman]

Romberg: String Quartet in A Minor, Op. 2/2

The finale has a great melody! It's immediately memorable. It's also cool how it is transformed from minor to major for the end of the movement. The opening theme of the first movement is also good, with effective use of pauses (where one might expect repetition of the previous notes). In the recapitulation, this first theme is changed to major, and the pauses are filled in. The minuet and trio also has an interesting structure: instead of repeating the  minuet, a new minuet developed from the original is played. The Op. 2 quartets were dedicated to Haydn, and there are some similarities.



Spotify link to finale: https://open.spotify.com/track/5z5SuXj647LOe3tTguj79J?si=0417909ed2a74adc