Leading tone question ( music theory ).

Started by SemiAnonymous, August 17, 2007, 04:50:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

SemiAnonymous


  Just here to ask one question... I hope that doesn't come across as too overtly usurious!
I'm trying to remember a music theory term for a particular "incorrect" resolution of the leading tone.
If, instead of resolving to the tonic, the leading tone is put in another voice ( say it was in the soprano and it switched to the tenor ) and then resolved or not resolved at all, for example:

B  going to G
G              Eb
D              C

  I remembering all this from years ago, so I'm rather hazy, but if anyone has any idea about what I'm talking about, it will be much appreciated.

PS: I'm not talking about an inner-voice descending leading tone one finds as a dominant seventh resolution.

hornteacher

I'm racking my brain right now.  As a music teacher I should know this (but to be fair I teach middle school kids so we don't get too deep into this).

I think it might be called an "Imperfect Authentic Cadence" (which is essentially a V-I resolution that does not resolve with proper voicings, i.e. bass and soprano on tonic and leading tones resolving).

A "Perfect Authentic Cadence" would look like this:

B  -  C
G  -  G
D  -  E
G  -  C

Any other voicing would be considered "Imperfect"

Someone help me if I'm wrong on this.

jochanaan

The word I remember is "deceptive."  The music sets up a certain resolution and then takes an unexpected turn. ;D
Imagination + discipline = creativity

Larry Rinkel

Quote from: jochanaan on August 18, 2007, 07:11:05 PM
The word I remember is "deceptive."  The music sets up a certain resolution and then takes an unexpected turn. ;D

A deceptive cadence would be something like V-VI, where the dominant resolves elsewhere than to the tonic - not what Semi is talking about here. Hornteacher is closer to the mark, as a perfect authentic cadence is V-I in root position with the soprano on the tonic note; all other variations are imperfect.

aquablob

Quote from: SemiAnonymous on August 17, 2007, 04:50:46 PM
  Just here to ask one question... I hope that doesn't come across as too overtly usurious!
I'm trying to remember a music theory term for a particular "incorrect" resolution of the leading tone.
If, instead of resolving to the tonic, the leading tone is put in another voice ( say it was in the soprano and it switched to the tenor ) and then resolved or not resolved at all, for example:

B  going to G
G              Eb
D              C

  I remembering all this from years ago, so I'm rather hazy, but if anyone has any idea about what I'm talking about, it will be much appreciated.

PS: I'm not talking about an inner-voice descending leading tone one finds as a dominant seventh resolution.

I don't know what term you are looking for (or if there even is one), but if I remember correctly, the leading tone "should" resolve upwards to the tonic in a V-I progression unless the following two conditions are met:

1. The leading tone in the V chord is in an inner voice;
AND
2. An adjacent voice (99% of the time, the upper adjacent voice) "fills the void," so to speak, by playing the expected tonic in the I chord.

In your example, the B meets neither of the above conditions. If we add a D above the B in the first chord, and have the D resolve downwards to the C in the second chord, the leading tone's downward motion (B to G) becomes "acceptable" (nevermind the parallel octaves we now have in the outer voices).

Holden

Quote from: Larry Rinkel on August 18, 2007, 08:13:14 PM
A deceptive cadence would be something like V-VI, where the dominant resolves elsewhere than to the tonic - not what Semi is talking about here. Hornteacher is closer to the mark, as a perfect authentic cadence is V-I in root position with the soprano on the tonic note; all other variations are imperfect.

..or possibly ending a piece in a minor key on a major chord as perfected by Bach?
Cheers

Holden

Szykneij

Quote from: Holden on August 18, 2007, 10:29:59 PM
..or possibly ending a piece in a minor key on a major chord as perfected by Bach?

Tierce di Picardie
Men profess to be lovers of music, but for the most part they give no evidence in their opinions and lives that they have heard it.  ~ Henry David Thoreau

Don't pray when it rains if you don't pray when the sun shines. ~ Satchel Paige