Topic: Wagner One Ring to rule them all...

[Biffo]

Here’s a question for everyone: I’m in the midst of ripping much of classical collection to my computer (and backing it up as well) and I want to rip one set of the Ring, but which one? Here are the ones I own: Böhm, Karajan, Solti, Barenboim and Janowski (on Sony).

I have all four of these and for me it would be between Solti and Karajan. I already have the Karajan as a lossless download (and on CD) but if that wasn't the case I would still go for Karajan.

[Mirror Image]

I have all four of these and for me it would be between Solti and Karajan. I already have the Karajan as a lossless download (and on CD) but if that wasn't the case I would still go for Karajan.

Thanks. Yes, I’m definitely leaning towards Karajan as well. His was the first Ring that made Wagner resonate with me on a deeper level. Solti never did this for me.

[Mirror Image]

I ended up buying the Boulez cycle for a decent price off eBay. Any thoughts on his set?



If anything, I’ll be able to hear Boulez’s laser-sharp conducting and how some of the textures and so forth are brought to the foreground that I have missed in other recordings.

So now I have quite a few Ring cycles: Karajan, Solti, Janowski (RCA), Böhm and Boulez.

[T. D.]

I owned a VHS of the Boulez-Chéreau Ring and watched it many times until my VHS player died, at which time I donated all of my old VHS to the local library.
Never ventured down the rabbit hole of searching for the best recorded Ring. Owned Solti and Levine (Jimmy's become a non-person and rightly so - prefer not to go there  - ; say what you want about his Ring cast but he was a helluva conductor), sampled some others, decided to stick with Solti and not venture further. I did add the Goodall Twilight of the Gods to have something very different. In the unlikely event I buy another Ring, it'll be one of the "classic" '50s vintage Bayreuth cycles (Krauss, Keilberth prominent candidates). Perhaps Goodall's Rhinegold at some point (D R and G are my favorites of the cycle).

[Mirror Image]

I owned a VHS of the Boulez-Chéreau Ring and watched it many times until my VHS player died, at which time I donated all of my old VHS to the local library.
Never ventured down the rabbit hole of searching for the best recorded Ring. Owned Solti and Levine (Jimmy's become a non-person and rightly so - prefer not to go there  - ; say what you want about his Ring cast but he was a helluva conductor), sampled some others, decided to stick with Solti and not venture further. I did add the Goodall Twilight of the Gods to have something very different. In the unlikely event I buy another Ring, it'll be one of the "classic" '50s vintage Bayreuth cycles (Krauss, Keilberth prominent candidates). Perhaps Goodall's Rhinegold at some point (D R and G are my favorites of the cycle).

Thanks for the feedback. I never cared about watching opera of any kind and I know this is important to the whole experience of opera, but I’ve always preferred listening without the visual aspect of it. I guess I’m weird like that. Also, I don’t really need to know what is being sung, but I do like reading of a synopsis of an opera before I start listening. I just like the whole aural experience and hearing how the music progresses. Anyway, Levine is a great conductor regardless of what he did. I’ll still listen to his recordings as there have been terrible things that a lot of musicians have done through the years, but this has never hindered my own enjoyment of their performances. Karajan is my Wagnerian of choice, but I would like to hear how Boulez fares in this music as I know he does have an attachment to the Austro-Germanic repertoire or at least that line of composers from Wagner, Mahler, the Second Viennese School, etc.

[T. D.]

As I've aged, I listen to opera recordings less because I miss the visual aspect! It's difficult to comment on the Boulez-Chéreau Ring because my memories are so linked to the visuals and the VHS sonics were not ultra-hi fi. I found nothing to criticize concerning the music, but some purists might not love the vocal cast.

[Biffo]

Thanks for the feedback. I never cared about watching opera of any kind and I know this is important to the whole experience of opera, but I’ve always preferred listening without the visual aspect of it. I guess I’m weird like that. Also, I don’t really need to know what is being sung, but I do like reading of a synopsis of an opera before I start listening. I just like the whole aural experience and hearing how the music progresses. Anyway, Levine is a great conductor regardless of what he did. I’ll still listen to his recordings as there have been terrible things that a lot of musicians have done through the years, but this has never hindered my own enjoyment of their performances. Karajan is my Wagnerian of choice, but I would like to hear how Boulez fares in this music as I know he does have an attachment to the Austro-Germanic repertoire or at least that line of composers from Wagner, Mahler, the Second Viennese School, etc.

You will have to let us know how you get on with Boulez and the Ring cycle. I have it on DVD and have watched/listened to it several times. Boulez favours brisk tempi which is not necessarily a bad thing but occasionally some of the great moments don't make their full effect.

Kempe is my favourite Wagnerian and it is a great pity that none of his complete cycles are in stereo. The best of them is from Bayreuth 1961 on Orfeo - the remastered mono sound is excellent. Personally, I prefer it to the much-hyped stereo of the Keilberth Bayreuth Ring.

[Mirror Image]

As I've aged, I listen to opera recordings less because I miss the visual aspect! It's difficult to comment on the Boulez-Chéreau Ring because my memories are so linked to the visuals and the VHS sonics were not ultra-hi fi. I found nothing to criticize concerning the music, but some purists might not love the vocal cast.

Like opera, I'm the same with ballet --- I don’t care nor have ever cared about choreography. I don’t care how its danced, I care about how the music is performed.

[Mirror Image]

You will have to let us know how you get on with Boulez and the Ring cycle. I have it on DVD and have watched/listened to it several times. Boulez favours brisk tempi which is not necessarily a bad thing but occasionally some of the great moments don't make their full effect.

Kempe is my favourite Wagnerian and it is a great pity that none of his complete cycles are in stereo. The best of them is from Bayreuth 1961 on Orfeo - the remastered mono sound is excellent. Personally, I prefer it to the much-hyped stereo of the Keilberth Bayreuth Ring.

It’ll probably be quite some time before I get the Boulez’s Ring truth be told as I have far too many irons in the fire right now. I kind of had a feeling that Boulez took things a bit quicker, but that’s alright because I do like hearing different kinds of interpretations. I listened to about 30 minutes or so of his Das Rheingold before I bought the complete set and I was rather enthralled with what I heard. The music had a forward momentum that I liked.

[Sergeant Rock]

Here’s a question for everyone: I’m in the midst of ripping much of classical collection to my computer (and backing it up as well) and I want to rip one set of the Ring, but which one? Here are the ones I own: Böhm, Karajan, Solti, Barenboim and Janowski (on Sony).

Karajan Das Rheingold
Karajan Act I Walküre
Barenboim Act II Walküre
Böhm Act III Walküre
Solti Siegfried
Levine Götterdämmerung (Oops, you don't have Levine so Karajan would be my second choice)

Sarge

[Mirror Image]

Karajan Das Rheingold
Karajan Act I Walküre
Barenboim Act II Walküre
Böhm Act III Walküre
Solti Siegfried
Levine Götterdämmerung (Oops, you don't have Levine so Karajan would be my second choice)

Sarge

Cool. Thanks, Sarge. But I’ve only got Karajan’s Ring ripped to my computer right now and I probably won’t be ripping any more Ring cycles. It looks like you lean heavily towards Karajan anyway. What do you think about Solti’s cycle? I’ve heard he’s more of a Straussian. Would you agree with this?

[Sergeant Rock]

Cool. Thanks, Sarge. But I’ve only got Karajan’s Ring ripped to my computer right now and I probably won’t be ripping any more Ring cycles. It looks like you lean heavily towards Karajan anyway. What do you think about Solti’s cycle? I’ve heard he’s more of a Straussian. Would you agree with this?

I do enjoy more of his Strauss operas. I own 13 Rings and Solti's is in the bottom half of the pile. But do I love his Siegfried (especially for Stolze's Mime and the confrontation with Fafner) and Tannhäuser.


Sarge

[Mirror Image]

I do enjoy more of his Strauss operas. I own 13 Rings and Solti's is in the bottom half of the pile. But do I love his Siegfried (especially for Stolze's Mime and the confrontation with Fafner) and Tannhäuser.


Sarge

Interesting. Good thing I didn’t rip the Solti yet.