Smetana

Started by wagnernn, October 09, 2007, 07:42:51 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

wagnernn

My friend asked me if the Smetana 's Trio in G minor was the greatest trio of all time.Do you think so?

BachQ

Quote from: wagnernn on October 09, 2007, 07:42:51 PM
My friend asked me if the Smetana 's Trio in G minor was the greatest trio of all time.Do you think so?

Yes.  Your friend is correct. 

val

No. It is a very nice work, but I think there are much better piano Trios: Beethoven opus 97, Schubert opus 100, Mendelssohn opus 49, Dvorak opus 65, Brahms opus 8 and 101, Fauré opus 120 and Ravel Trio in A minor.

Smetana himself composed chamber music that I think much more inspired, above all the remarkable and tragic first Quartet.

wagnernn

In my opinion,just the last movement of this trio is  wonderful .And which trio of the Romantic era do you call "the greatest"?

Bonehelm

Quote from: wagnernn on October 10, 2007, 07:10:26 PM
In my opinion,just the last movement of this trio is  wonderful .And which trio of the Romantic era do you call "the greatest"?

In art, nothing can be measured against one another. You can only ask, "What are some other trios in the Romantic era that are really great?".

The new erato

Quote from: Bonehelm on October 10, 2007, 07:29:18 PM
In art, nothing can be measured against one another. You can only ask, "What are some other trios in the Romantic era that are really great?".
Problem is that with that logic you could also say; Smetana's trio isn't that great. Which lead us to all the trios that are greater than Smetana's, a goood list seems to have been proposed by Val, nailing a lot of my favorites.