Composer elimination game

[Bogey]

The "Zebra" has spoken (great avatar David).  Here's how it stands and the next voter can play Caesar with Verdi's fate:

JS Bach  8
Beethoven 9
Berg 4
Brahms 6
Bruckner 6
Chopin 7
Dvorak 5
Haydn  7
Handel 3
Mahler 8
Monteverdi 6
Mozart 6
Schubert 6
Schoenberg 4
Shostakovich 5
Stravinsky 5
Tchaikovsky 5
Verdi  1

[greg]

JS Bach  8
Beethoven 9
Berg 5           +
Brahms 6
Bruckner 6
Chopin 6      -
Dvorak 5
Haydn  7
Handel 3
Mahler 8
Monteverdi 6
Mozart 6
Schubert 6
Schoenberg 4
Shostakovich 5
Stravinsky 5
Tchaikovsky 5
Verdi  1



gee...... i wonder who's going next? 

[Papy Oli]

JS Bach  8
Beethoven 9
Berg 5
Brahms 6
Bruckner 6
Chopin 6     
Dvorak 5
Haydn  7
Handel 3
Mahler 8 + 1 = 9
Monteverdi 6
Mozart 6
Schubert 6
Schoenberg 4 - 1 = 3
Shostakovich 5
Stravinsky 5
Tchaikovsky 5
Verdi  1

[greg]

Schoenberg  = 3

NOOOOOOOO!!!!!!! help, Karl!

[longears]

The "Zebra" has spoken (great avatar David).  Here's how it stands and the next voter can play Caesar with Verdi's fate

But Bill--after my vote, Verdi stood at +3.  The risk of losing him so prematurely before less worthy adversaries stirred my from my slumber and prompted my pre-dawn posting!  Zounds!

And after your vote, Schoenberg stood at +2

[Gurn Blanston]

JS Bach  8
Beethoven 9  + =10
Berg 5
Brahms 6
Bruckner 6
Chopin 6     
Dvorak 5
Haydn  7
Handel 3
Mahler 9   - =8
Monteverdi 6
Mozart 6
Schubert 6
Schoenberg 3
Shostakovich 5
Stravinsky 5
Tchaikovsky 5
Verdi  1

[karlhenning]

JS Bach  8
Beethoven 9 (-)
Berg 5
Brahms 6
Bruckner 6
Chopin 6     
Dvorak 5
Haydn  7
Handel 3
Mahler 8
Monteverdi 6
Mozart 6
Schubert 6
Schoenberg 3
Shostakovich 5
Stravinsky 5
Tchaikovsky 5
Verdi  2 (+)

[Drasko]

JS Bach  8
Beethoven 8 (-)
Berg 5
Brahms 6
Bruckner 6
Chopin 6     
Dvorak 5
Haydn  7
Handel 3
Mahler 8
Monteverdi 6
Mozart 6
Schubert 6
Schoenberg 3
Shostakovich 5
Stravinsky 5
Tchaikovsky 5
Verdi  3 (+)

[longears]

So with corrections, after Karl& Drasko's votes, it should be:

JS Bach  8
Beethoven 8
Berg 5
Brahms 6
Bruckner 6
Chopin 6     
Dvorak 5
Haydn  7
Handel 3
Mahler 8
Monteverdi 6
Mozart 6
Schubert 6
Schoenberg 1
Shostakovich 5
Stravinsky 5
Tchaikovsky 5
Verdi  5

[Bogey]

But Bill--after my vote, Verdi stood at +3.  The risk of losing him so prematurely before less worthy adversaries stirred my from my slumber and prompted my pre-dawn posting!  Zounds!

And after your vote, Schoenberg stood at +2

Right you are David....I had a Florida moment.

[karlhenning]

So with corrections, after Karl& Drasko's votes, it should be:

JS Bach  8
Beethoven 8
Berg 5
Brahms 6
Bruckner 6
Chopin 6     
Dvorak 5
Haydn  7
Handel 3
Mahler 8
Monteverdi 6
Mozart 6
Schubert 6
Schoenberg 1
Shostakovich 5
Stravinsky 5
Tchaikovsky 5
Verdi  5

Oh!

In that case, I shift my (+) vote to Schoenberg, thus:

JS Bach  8
Beethoven 8
Berg 5
Brahms 6
Bruckner 6
Chopin 6    
Dvorak 5
Haydn  7
Handel 3
Mahler 8
Monteverdi 6
Mozart 6
Schubert 6
Schoenberg 2
Shostakovich 5
Stravinsky 5
Tchaikovsky 5
Verdi  4

[greg]

good move!

[springrite]

Beethoven 9 (-)

You are a brave man, Karl!

[Scriptavolant]

JS Bach  8
Beethoven 8
Berg 5
Brahms 6
Bruckner 6
Chopin 6   
Dvorak 5
Haydn  7
Handel 4 +
Mahler 8
Monteverdi 6
Mozart 6
Schubert 6
Schoenberg 2
Shostakovich 5
Stravinsky 5
Tchaikovsky 4 -
Verdi  4

[karlhenning]

You are a brave man, Karl!

Nothing against Beethoven; it's a question of weighting, is all.

[karlhenning]

Delightful av, Scriptavolant!

[Mark G. Simon]

JS Bach  8
Beethoven 8
Berg 5
Brahms 6
Bruckner 6
Chopin 6    
Dvorak 5
Haydn  7
Handel 4
Mahler 8
Monteverdi 6
Mozart 6
Schubert 6
Schoenberg 2
Shostakovich 5
Stravinsky 5 + 1 = 6
Tchaikovsky 4
Verdi  4

I refuse to give a minus

[springrite]

After votes from the yet unborn Kimi SpringRite:

JS Bach  8
Beethoven 8
Berg 5
Brahms 6
Bruckner 6 (-1=) 5
Chopin 6     
Dvorak 5
Haydn  7
Handel 3
Mahler 8
Monteverdi 6
Mozart 6
Schubert 6
Schoenberg 2 (+1 )= 3
Shostakovich 5
Stravinsky 5 + 1 = 6
Tchaikovsky 5
Verdi  4

[(poco) Sforzando]

Wagner + 1

No one deserves a minus on that list either.

[Keemun]

JS Bach  8
Beethoven 8
Berg 5
Brahms 6
Bruckner 6 +
Chopin 6     
Dvorak 5
Haydn  7
Handel 3
Mahler 8
Monteverdi 6
Mozart 6
Schubert 6
Schoenberg 2 -
Shostakovich 5
Stravinsky 6
Tchaikovsky 5
Verdi  4