Composers Hall of Fame Game.

[BachQ]

R. Schumann 12
R. Strauss 10
Bruckner 18 ++
Copland 8 --
Martin 4
Honegger 12
Part 16
Messiaen 6
Barber 8
Penderecki 10

[Anne]

R. Schumann 12
R. Strauss 10
                     (Bruckner 20 ++)
Copland 6 --
Martin 4
Honegger 12
Part 16
Messiaen 6
Barber 8
Penderecki 10

Gluck 10

[Bogey]

R. Schumann 12
R. Strauss 10
Copland 8++
Martin 2--
Honegger 12
Part 16
Messiaen 6
Barber 8
Penderecki 10
Gluck 10

[The Emperor]

UPDATE
HALL OF FAME - J.S.BACH, SIBELIUS, BEETHOVEN, MOZART, SHOSTAKOVICH, BRAHMS, RACHMANINOV, TCHAIKOVSKY, PROKOFIEV, SCHUBERT, STRAVINSKY, MUSSORGSKY, MAHLER, BARTOK, NORGARD, DEBUSSY, BRUCKNER

PURGATORY - LISZT, HAYDN, ATTERBERG, SCRIABIN, IVES, MARTIN

HELL - CHOPIN, RALPH VAUGHAN WILLIAMS, DVORAK, LIGETI, BYRD, BUXTEHUDE, RUBINSTEIN, SCHOENBERG. HANDEL

[longears]

R. Schumann 12-2=10
R. Strauss 10
Copland 8
Martin 2
Honegger 12
Part 16
Messiaen 6
Barber 8+2=10
Penderecki 10
Gluck 10

[Don]

R. Schumann 10 + 2 = 12
R. Strauss 10
Copland 8
Martin 2
Honegger 12
Part 16
Messiaen 6
Barber 10
Penderecki 10 - 2 = 8
Gluck 10

[greg]

R. Schumann 12
R. Strauss 10
Copland 8
Martin 0  -
Honegger 12
Part 16
Messiaen 6
Barber 10
Penderecki 10 +
Gluck 10


add:
Gorecki 10

[btpaul674]

R. Schumann 12
R. Strauss 10
Copland 6 (--)
Honegger 12
Part 18 (++)
Messiaen 6
Barber 10
Penderecki 10
Gluck 10
Gorecki 10

[not edward]

R. Schumann 12
R. Strauss 10
Copland 6
Honegger 14 (++)
Part 18
Messiaen 6
Barber 10
Penderecki 10
Gluck 10
Gorecki 8 (--)

[Symphonien]

R. Schumann 12
R. Strauss 10
Copland 4 (-)
Honegger 14
Pärt 20 (HALL OF FAME)
Messiaen 6
Barber 10
Penderecki 10
Gluck 10
Gorecki 8

Add:

Schnittke 10

[Brian]

Suggestion: after a few more months of this, you post the list of composers who are in Heaven and Hell in a separate thread, and ask: Would you rather go to heaven or hell?  0:)

[Brian]

From Good Omens, by Neil Gaiman and Terry Pratchett:

"Listen," said [the demon] Crowley, desperately, "how many musicians do you think your side have got, eh? First grade, I mean."

Aziraphale [the angel] looked taken aback. "Well, I should think-" he began.

"Two," said Crowley. "Elgar and Liszt. That's all. We've got the rest. Beethoven, Brahms, all the Bachs, Mozart, the lot. Can you imagine eternity with Elgar?"

Aziraphale shut his eyes. "All too easily," he groaned.

[Kullervo]

R. Schumann 12
R. Strauss 10
Copland 4
Honegger 14 + 2 = 16
Messiaen 6
Barber 10
Penderecki 10
Gluck 10
Gorecki 8 - 2 = 6
Schnittke 10

[The Emperor]

UPDATE
HALL OF FAME - J.S.BACH, SIBELIUS, BEETHOVEN, MOZART, SHOSTAKOVICH, BRAHMS, RACHMANINOV, TCHAIKOVSKY, PROKOFIEV, SCHUBERT, STRAVINSKY, MUSSORGSKY, MAHLER, BARTOK, NORGARD, DEBUSSY, BRUCKNER, PART

PURGATORY - LISZT, HAYDN, ATTERBERG, SCRIABIN, IVES, MARTIN, COPLAND

HELL - CHOPIN, RALPH VAUGHAN WILLIAMS, DVORAK, LIGETI, BYRD, BUXTEHUDE, RUBINSTEIN, SCHOENBERG. HANDEL

R. Schumann 12
R. Strauss 10
Copland 4-2=2
Honegger  16
Messiaen 6
Barber 10
Penderecki 10
Gluck 10
Gorecki  6
Schnittke 10+2=12

[Siedler]

R. Schumann 10
R. Strauss 12 +
Copland 0 -
Honegger  16
Messiaen 6
Barber 10
Penderecki 10
Gluck 10
Gorecki  6
Schnittke 12
Verdi 10

[BachQ]

Copland 0 -

Bogey's gonna be pissed ........

[Morigan]

R. Schumann 10
R. Strauss 12 +
Copland 0 -
Honegger  16
Messiaen 6
Barber 10
Penderecki 10
Gluck 10
Gorecki  6
Schnittke 12
Verdi 10

Err, why did Schumann suddenly lose two points?

[The Emperor]

Yeh he has 12. next one to vote remember Schumann =12

[greg]

R. Schumann 10
R. Strauss 12
Honegger  16
Messiaen 6
Barber 10
Penderecki 10
Gluck 8   -
Gorecki  6
Schnittke 14   +
Verdi 10

[Don]

R. Schumann 12 + 2 = 14
R. Strauss 12
Honegger 16 - 2 = 14
Messiaen 6
Barber 10
Penderecki 10
Gluck 8
Gorecki 6
Schnittke 14
Verdi 10