The Music Room > Composing and Performing

Taking Up Two Stringed Instruments

(1/2) > >>

Haffner:
I'm looking to take up both viola and cello as musical instruments in the next month. Is this not a good idea?

I've got plenty of time to practice and study, and I've played guitar for over 13 years now. Will the carry over form one stringed instruments help me with these two others?

I am hoping to help my string-composing abilities by taking up these two instruments also.

Finally, is it pretty much mandatory that I see a teacher, at least in the very beginning period?

Any help would be deeply appreciated, I am very excited about learning much more about these two favorite instruments of minel

greg:
Now..... are you really trying to learn how to play them just so you know more about the instrument or are you trying to master them?
I'd advise only taking up one instrument seriously and then more or less messing around with the other, though I don't know exactly what your goals are for each instrument.....

This is similar to me taking up 2 languages at the same time, which was NOT a good idea to start with, you should get really good at one, and then move on to another.

I don't know exactly how similar it feels to play those instruments compared to a guitar, but the tuning is different it's a whole new system, not to mention a whole new playing technique- but still, knowing how to play the guitar does help a bit, it's like a kick start.

Heather Harrison:
I haven't ever played guitar, so I wouldn't be too familiar with the differences (although I know the tuning system is different).  Taking up two instruments at the same time might add to the difficulty unless the instruments are quite similar to each other.  I took up viola and violin at the same time, but those are more similar to each other than viola and cello.  My main focus is the viola, while I play the violin just to get some variety (and to get used to reading the treble clef).

On these instruments, I would strongly recommend that you see a teacher; it is all too easy to pick up bad habits, and the feedback is useful.  These really aren't do-it-yourself instruments.

If you want a bowed-string instrument that is more similar to the guitar, the viola da gamba might be an interesting choice, although it might be difficult to find lessons.  Most varieties have six strings and the tuning is similar to guitar tuning.  I'm thinking of trying this some day, but probably not until I have more experience.

Heather

Haffner:

--- Quote from: Heather Harrison on April 29, 2007, 11:10:10 AM ---I haven't ever played guitar, so I wouldn't be too familiar with the differences (although I know the tuning system is different).  Taking up two instruments at the same time might add to the difficulty unless the instruments are quite similar to each other.  I took up viola and violin at the same time, but those are more similar to each other than viola and cello.  My main focus is the viola, while I play the violin just to get some variety (and to get used to reading the treble clef).

On these instruments, I would strongly recommend that you see a teacher; it is all too easy to pick up bad habits, and the feedback is useful.  These really aren't do-it-yourself instruments.

If you want a bowed-string instrument that is more similar to the guitar, the viola da gamba might be an interesting choice, although it might be difficult to find lessons.  Most varieties have six strings and the tuning is similar to guitar tuning.  I'm thinking of trying this some day, but probably not until I have more experience.

Heather

--- End quote ---




Thanks so much, Heather!

Guido:
You must see a teacher. The other advice has been very good so far, but I just thought I'd stress this again! String instruments are probably the most time consuming and difficult instruments to learn the fundamentals of, much more so than say piano, which you could, with difficulty teach yourself to a basic level. Be warned that the initial few years will probably be quite unrewarding if you are already good at another instrument, and they can be very frustrating. There are no frets! Which means that they are also the most difficult instruments tuning wise - there are an infinite possibility of notes that you can play, so obviously tuning is not something that will come quickly (and it plagues even the greatest of professionals).

Learning a string instrument is a long and arduous path, but the results will be all the more rewarding because of it.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

Go to full version