Weakest Link: Revolver: Round Two

[George]

The Yellow Submarine sank, along with Dr. Robert. I want to tell you that I want to tell you also got voted off.

Again, choose 3 to go. I know this is impossible, but you can do it!

Poll closes in 24 Hours.

Discussion question: Who is your favorite Beatle and why?

[hornteacher]

Discussion question: Who is your favorite Beatle and why?

George was my favorite with John a very close second.

When it comes to the music, Paul's was the prettiest, Ringo's was the most fun, but John's appealed to the mind, and George's stirred the soul.

[Gurn Blanston]

C'mon, HT, let's not get all poetic here, it's just pop music...    

I liked George's music the best, he seemed to be in the minor mode a lot, still my favorite.



----------------
Listening to:

Dvorak B 120 - Vlach Quartet Prague - Dvorak Quartettsatz in F    B 120

[Gurn Blanston]

Oh.
Love You Too
Tomorrow Never knows
Good day, Sunshine


----------------
Listening to:
Dvorak B 120 - Vlach Quartet Prague - Dvorak Quartettsatz in F    B 120

[Haffner]

I'm Only..., Love You, and though I actually hesitated, Good Day...

[George]

Tomorrow Never knows

The lay down all thought line wasn't mean to be taken literally. 

[George]

This is going to be a tight race, my friends. 

[MN Dave]

Favorite Beatle: Paul

I think he wrote the best music even if his lyrics weren't that great but this is pop music so who cares that much about the lyrics? 

My votes off Revolver Island:

Love You Too
Good Day, Sunshine
Got to Get You Into My Life

[George]

Discussion question: Who is your favorite Beatle and why?

George, no -

Paul.

Because his singing was almost always note perfect. His songs seem to show a vulnerability I admire.

[MN Dave]

George, no -

Paul.

Because his singing was almost always note perfect. His songs seem to show a vulnerability I admire.

Yeah, great voice.

[George]

Yeah, great voice.

I noticed that For No One has not got one vote yet, in either round. (the only song in this category) You guys have good taste. 

[Shrunk]

Voted Love You To, Good Day Sunshine and Got to Get You Into My Life.  The last one was the hardest, but the real heartbreakers are coming up.

John.

[J.Z. Herrenberg]

Lennon.

[The new erato]

Voted Love You To, Good Day Sunshine and Got to Get You Into My Life.  The last one was the hardest, but the real heartbreakers are coming up.

John.

Me too.

[jwinter]

Hate to bum you out George, but I went for...

She Said She Said
Good Day Sunshine
For No One (it's by no means a bad song, but tough decisions must be made -- we're at war, dang it!  )

Favorite Beatle -- John, no doubt about it.

[Sergeant Rock]

I'm Only Sleeping
She Said She Said
Got To Get You Into My Life


Favorite Beatle:

Paul, the Wimpmeister? Nah. George, the space cadet? Nah. John, the pseudo-firebrand? Nah. Ringo, the clown? Oh, yeah! 

Sarge

[George]

Hate to bum you out George, but I went for...

She Said She Said
Good Day Sunshine
For No One (it's by no means a bad song, but tough decisions must be made -- we're at war, dang it!  )

Now I know what it's like to be dead.

[MN Dave]

Paul, the Wimpmeister?

Yeah, the wimpmeister who wrote "Helter Skelter" and "I'm Down."  

[Sergeant Rock]

Yeah, the wimpmeister who wrote "Helter Skelter" and "I'm Down." 

Yeah, that's the one! 

Sarge

[hornteacher]

C'mon, HT, let's not get all poetic here, it's just pop music...    

   Philistine.