GMG Classical Music Forum

The Music Room => General Classical Music Discussion => The Polling Station => Topic started by: PaulR on September 17, 2014, 04:49:06 PM

Poll
Question: Original Ending or Revised 1872 Ending
Option 1: Original Ending (Death of Boris) votes: 1
Option 2: Revised 1872 Ending (Holy Fool weeping for Russia) votes: 1
Option 3: No Preference votes: 0
Title: Preferred Boris Godunov Ending
Post by: PaulR on September 17, 2014, 04:49:06 PM
Just an idle curiosity, but I have been thinking about this for myself.

The Original 1869 Version ends with the death of Boris Godunov, while the 1872 version adds the additional kromi forest scene that ends with the Holy Fool Weeping for Russia's future.

For me, I think I like the original version's ending better.  While the 1872 version might be closer to Pushkin in spirit (even though Mussorgsky invented the scene), I think the original version has a more conclusive ending of the drama itself due to the death of Boris.  I enjoy both endings though, and I do like how some modern productions include the Kromi forest scene in the otherwise 1869 version.

I'll expand my thoughts later.
Title: Re: Preferred Boris Godunov Ending
Post by: vandermolen on September 20, 2014, 01:20:08 PM
Definitely the one with the Simpleton at the end. I saw a production in London years ago where he emerges from a pile of bodies on stage, sings his lament and then slowly sinks down again on the pile - I found it unbearably moving - truly wonderful and it has stayed with me ever since.