All shed a tear for what was once by far the greatest source for music scores online. It seems the EU isn't cool with people from their country viewing what is public domain in Canada. Who knows when and in what form it will pop up as next? :'(
www.imslp.org
Quote from: JCampbell on October 21, 2007, 11:13:57 PM
All shed a tear for what was once by far the greatest source for music scores online. It seems the EU isn't cool with people from their country viewing what is public domain in Canada. Who knows when and in what form it will pop up as next? :'(
www.imslp.org
It is a fantasy to believe that everything "intellectual" is somehow free: for things still in the private domain, you should pay a price for it. If you want e.g. a score of Penderecki's latest effort, then you have to pay, and rightly so.
For things in the
public domain, okay, no problem: the agreement is that after so many years, the artist has received a just compensation, and it can now float at any price, or at no price, in the ether.
It shows the need for universal copyright rules, at least in respect to thee moment that copyrights expire.
I happen to know that many European countries had, like Canada, also a minimum expiry period of 50 years.
But Germany, which had a much longer minimum - of 75 years I believe - staunchly defended it during the negations on a uniform rule for the whole EU. 70 years was the compromise, so Germany clearly won.
Q
Cato & Que have packaged up the main points quite nicely.
I like "free" music as much as the next guy, but the publishers and their artists need to make money, so the laws exist and need to be enforced.
I wondered: why didn't the site in question simply remove all material that is still covered by US or EU copyrights, instead of shutting down completely?
Q
I read the thread name as "RIP ASLSP"... I assumed that the Organ2/ASLSP (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/As_Slow_As_Possible) endevour had been abandoned :P
Quote from: Que on October 22, 2007, 08:15:24 AM
I wondered: why didn't the site in question simply remove all material that is still covered by US or EU copyrights, instead of shutting down completely?
Q
I wondered it too, Q. Here's a list of the alleged offenders from a post on the imslp forums. Apparently even some of the deviants are necessarily under copyright.
Quote from: Carolus
Just to have the list handy, here are the titles UE is upset about:
Bartók Béla (1881-1945)
Allegro Barbaro (pub.1918, UE) - IMSLP has a Muzika ed.
Bagatelles, Op. 6 (pub.1909, Rozsnyai) - IMSLP has a Muzika ed.
Burlesques, Op. 8c (pub.1912, Rozsavolgyi) - IMSLP has a Muzika ed.
Improvisations on Hungarian Peasant Songs, Op. 20 (pub.1921, UE) - IMSLP has a Muzika ed.
Little Pieces for Piano (pub.1927, UE) - IMSLP has a Muzika ed.
Petite Suite for Piano (pub.1936, UE) - IMSLP has a Muzika ed.
Piano Concerto No. 1 (pub.1927, UE)
Piano Concerto No. 2 (pub.1932, UE) - IMSLP has a Muzika ed.
Piano Concerto No. 3 (pub.1947, Boosey & Hawkes) - IMSLP has a Muzika ed.
[Four] Piano Pieces (pub.1904 Bard Farenc) - IMSLP also has Muzika ed.
Piano Sonata (pub.1927, UE)
Rhapsody, Op. 1 (pub.1908, Rozsavolgyi) - IMSLP has a Muzika ed.
Romanian Christmas Carols (pub.1918, UE)
Romanian Folk Dances for small orchestra (pub.1922, UE)
Romanian Folk Dances (pub.1918, UE)
[3] Rondos on Slovak Folk Tunes (pub.1930, UE) - IMSLP has a Muzika ed.
Sonatina (pub.1919, Rozsavolgyi) - IMSLP also has 1950 rev. ed.
String Quartet No. 1, Op.7 (pub.1911, Rozsavolgyi)
String Quartet No. 2, Op.17 (pub.1920, UE)
String Quartet No. 3 (pub.1929, UE)
String Quartet No. 4 (pub.1929, UE)
String Quartet No. 5 (pub.1936, UE)
Suite for Piano, Op. 14 (pub.1918, UE) - IMSLP also has Muzika ed.
Berg Alban (1885-1935)
5 Orchesterlieder, Op. 4 - no longer at IMSLP
Piano Sonata, Op. 1 (pub. 1910, rev.1920 Lienau)
Violin Concerto "To the Memory of an Angel" (pub.1936, UE)
Friedman Ignaz (1882-1948)
6 Mazurkas, Op. 85 (pub.1925, UE)
Piano Transcriptions (Grazioli) (pub.1913, UE)
Piano Transcriptions (Rameau) (pub.1913, 1914 UE)
3 Pieces, Op. 33 (pub.1911, UE)
Polnische Lyrik, Op. 53 (pub.1913, UE)
Polnische Lyrik, Op. 60 (pub.1915, UE)
Polnische Lyrik, Op. 72 (pub.1917, UE)
4 Preludes, Op. 48 (pub.1912, UE)
4 Preludes, Op. 61 (pub.1915, UE)
Stimmungen, Op. 79 (pub.1918, UE)
Studies on a Theme of Paganini, Op. 47b (pub.1914, UE)
5 Waltzes, Op. 51 (pub.1912, UE)
With the Marionettes, Op. 22 (pub.1920, UE)
Janacek, Leos (1854-1928)
Violin Sonata [No. 3] (pub.1922, Hudebni Matice)
Mahler Gustav (1860-1911)
Piano Quartet in A Minor - no longer at IMSLP
Symphony No. 1 (pub.1898, Weiinberger, rev.1906, UE)
Symphony No. 2 (pub.1897, Hofmeister, rev.1906, UE)
Symphony No. 8 (pub.1910, UE)
Marx Joseph (1882-1964)
Albumblatt (pub.1916, UE)
Ballade (pub.1916, UE)
Prelude and Fugue (pub.1916, UE)
Romantic Piano Concerto (pub.1920, UE)
Trio Phantasie (pub.1914, UE)
Respighi, Ottorino (1879-1936)
3 Preludes (pub.1920, UE)
Schönberg, Arnold (1874-1951)
2 Balladen, Op. 12 (pub.1920, UE)
15 Gedichte aus Das Buch der hängenden Gärten, Op. 15 (pub.1914, UE)
2 Gesänge für baritone, Op. 1 (pub.1903, Birnbach)
Klavierstücke, Op. 33a (pub.1929, UE)
4 Lieder, Op. 2 (pub.1903, Birnbach)
6 Lieder, Op. 3 (pub.1904, Birnbach)
8 Lieder, Op. 6 (pub.1907, Birnbach)
2 Lieder, Op. 14 (pub.1920, UE)
2 Little Piano Pieces, Op. 19 (pub.1913, UE)
3 Pieces, Op. 11 (pub.1916, UE)
Pierrot Lunaire, Op. 21 (pub.1914, UE)
Suite. Op. 25 (pub.1925, UE)
Verklärte Nacht. Op. 4 (pub.1904, Birnbach)
Strauss, Richard (1864-1949)
Piano Sonata, Op. 5 (pub.1883 Jos. Aibl)
Szymanowski, Karol (1882-1937)
4 Etudes, Op. 4 (pub.1906, UE)
Metopes, Op. 29 (pub.1922, UE)
Piano Sonata No. 2, Op. 21 (pub.1912, UE)
9 Preludes, Op. 1 (pub.1906, UE)
Variations on a Polish Folk Theme, Op. 10 (pub.1906, UE)
Zemlinsky, Alexander von (1871-1942)
6 Songs after Poems by Maeterlink, Op. 13 (pub.1914, UE)
Right off the bat, all but one (Joseph Marx) of the composers listed is very clearly public domain in Canada. The only way a work of one of these composers could be still under copyright in Canada is if it were first published less than 50 years ago (before 1957). I also note they list four composers (Berg, Janacek, Mahler, Respighi) who have been dead for more than 70 years who are PD in the EU. Moreover, Szymanowski will go public domain in the life-plus-70 countries (like Austria and Poland) on Jan. 1, 2008. Joseph Marx (d.1964) is still under copyright in Canada. Any work that was first published before 1923 is public domain in the US (the vast majority of titles listed above).
Thread here:
http://imslpforums.org/viewtopic.php?t=609
QuoteIMSLP has a Muzika ed
This is the key.
I have a question....wasn't the Bartok Concerto for Orchestra at IMSLP? :( Did anyone manage to get it?