Innovative Composer Game (Round One)

Started by Sammy, March 30, 2018, 04:43:56 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Print
Go Down Pages1 2 3 ... 6
User actions

Sammy

March 30, 2018, 04:43:56 PM
We have arrived at Round One of our Innovative Composer Game.  After a few days of selecting composers, there are a total of 58 for our voting pleasure.  I have broken the total down into 2 rounds, each round having 29 entries.  For each round, the 10 composers ending up with the highest scores will advance to the final round.

Voting Rules:

1.  You may vote once daily.

2.  Each composer starts the round with zero points.

3.  When you vote, you will have 10 upward points to distribute as you please except that no composer may receive more than 5 points.

4.  Round One ends with the first composer to reach 100 points.

5.  The Half-Time Adjustment is in effect.  With the first composer to garner 50 points, the 10 composers having the lowest scores will be eliminated from the game; this number could rise if there are ties toward the bottom of the board.

Think Creatively:

Bach (CPE) - 0
Bach (JS) - 0
Bartok - 0
Beethoven - 5 (+5)
Bellini - 0
Berg - 0
Berlioz-  0
Biber - 0
Brahms - 0

Boulanger (L.) - 0
Boulez - 0
Caccini - 0
Cage - 5 (+5)
Carter - 0
Chopin - 0
Corelli - 0
Debussy - 0
Dufay - 0
Dunstable - 0

Ferrari - 0
Gesualdo - 0
Gluck - 0
Grainger - 0
Hauer - 0
Haydn (J.) - 0
Hildegard von Bingen - 0
Ives - 0
Janáček - 0
Koechlin - 0

Cato

#1
March 30, 2018, 04:49:01 PM
Bach (CPE) - 0
Bach (JS) - 0
Bartok - 0
Beethoven - 5 (+5)
Bellini - 0
Berg - 0
Berlioz-  0
Biber - 0
Brahms - 0

Boulanger (L.) - 0
Boulez - 0
Caccini - 0
Cage - 5 (+5)
Carter - 0
Chopin - 0
Corelli - 0
Debussy - 0
Dufay - 0
Dunstable - 0

Ferrari - 0
Gesualdo - 5 (+ 5)
Gluck - 0
Grainger - 0
Hauer - 0
Haydn (J.) - 0
Hildegard von Bingen - 0
Ives - 5 (+ 5)
Janáček - 0
Koechlin - 0
"Meet Miss Ruth Sherwood, from Columbus, Ohio, the Middle of the Universe!"

- Brian Aherne introducing Rosalind Russell in  My Sister Eileen (1942)

mc ukrneal

#2
March 30, 2018, 04:53:59 PM

Bach (CPE) - 0
Bach (JS) - 0
Bartok - 0
Beethoven - 5
Bellini - 0
Berg - 0
Berlioz-  0
Biber - 0
Brahms - 0

Boulanger (L.) - 0
Boulez - 0
Caccini - 0
Cage - 5
Carter - 0
Chopin - 0
Corelli - 0
Debussy - 0
Dufay - 0
Dunstable - 0

Ferrari - 0
Gesualdo - 10 (+ 5)
Gluck - 0
Grainger - 0
Hauer - 0
Haydn (J.) - 0
Hildegard von Bingen - 0
Ives - 10 (+ 5)
Janáček - 0
Koechlin - 0

I agree with you. See, it does happen! :)
Be kind to your fellow posters!!

ComposerOfAvantGarde

#3
March 30, 2018, 05:07:49 PM
Bach (CPE) - 0
Bach (JS) - 0
Bartok - 0
Beethoven - 5
Bellini - 0
Berg - 0
Berlioz-  0
Biber - 0
Brahms - 3 (+3)

Boulanger (L.) - 0
Boulez - 5 (+5)
Caccini - 0
Cage - 5
Carter - 0
Chopin - 0
Corelli - 0
Debussy - 0
Dufay - 0
Dunstable - 0

Ferrari - 0
Gesualdo - 10
Gluck - 0
Grainger - 2 (+2)
Hauer - 0
Haydn (J.) - 0
Hildegard von Bingen - 0
Ives - 10
Janáček - 0
Koechlin - 0

Madiel

#4
March 30, 2018, 05:32:42 PM
Bach (CPE) - 0
Bach (JS) - 0
Bartok - 0
Beethoven - 7 (+2)
Bellini - 0
Berg - 0
Berlioz-  0
Biber - 0
Brahms - 3

Boulanger (L.) - 0
Boulez - 5
Caccini - 0
Cage - 5
Carter - 0
Chopin - 2 (+2)
Corelli - 0
Debussy - 3 (+3)
Dufay - 0
Dunstable - 0

Ferrari - 0
Gesualdo - 10
Gluck - 0
Grainger - 2
Hauer - 0
Haydn (J.) - 3 (+3)
Hildegard von Bingen - 0
Ives - 10
Janáček - 0
Koechlin - 0
Nobody has to apologise for using their brain.

Mahlerian

#5
March 30, 2018, 05:33:23 PM
Bach (CPE) - 0
Bach (JS) - 0
Bartok - 0
Beethoven - 7
Bellini - 0
Berg - 0
Berlioz-  2 (+2)
Biber - 0
Brahms - 3

Boulanger (L.) - 0
Boulez - 5
Caccini - 0
Cage - 5
Carter - 0
Chopin - 2
Corelli - 0
Debussy - 8 (+5)
Dufay - 0
Dunstable - 0

Ferrari - 0
Gesualdo - 10
Gluck - 0
Grainger - 2
Hauer - 0
Haydn (J.) - 6 (+3)
Hildegard von Bingen - 0
Ives - 10
Janáček - 0
Koechlin - 0
"l do not consider my music as atonal, but rather as non-tonal. I feel the unity of all keys. Atonal music by modern composers admits of no key at all, no feeling of any definite center." - Arnold Schoenberg

André

#6
March 30, 2018, 05:38:05 PM
Bach (CPE) - 3 (+3)
Bach (JS) - 0
Bartok - 0
Beethoven - 7
Bellini - 2 (+2)
Berg - 0
Berlioz-  2
Biber - 0
Brahms - 3

Boulanger (L.) - 0
Boulez - 5
Caccini - 0
Cage - 5
Carter - 0
Chopin - 2
Corelli - 0
Debussy - 8
Dufay - 0
Dunstable - 0

Ferrari - 0
Gesualdo - 10
Gluck - 0
Grainger - 2
Hauer - 0
Haydn (J.) - 8 (+2)
Hildegard von Bingen - 0
Ives - 10
Janáček - 0
Koechlin - 3 (+3)

San Antone

#7
March 30, 2018, 05:53:04 PM
Bach (CPE) - 3
Bach (JS) - 0
Bartok - 0
Beethoven - 7
Bellini - 2
Berg - 0
Berlioz-  2
Biber - 0
Brahms - 3

Boulanger (L.) - 0
Boulez - 5
Caccini - 0
Cage - 10 (+5)
Carter - 0
Chopin - 2
Corelli - 0
Debussy - 13 (+5)
Dufay - 0
Dunstable - 0

Ferrari - 0
Gesualdo - 10
Gluck - 0
Grainger - 2
Hauer - 0
Haydn (J.) - 8
Hildegard von Bingen - 0
Ives - 10
Janáček - 0
Koechlin - 3

GioCar

#8
March 30, 2018, 08:35:36 PM
Bach (CPE) - 3
Bach (JS) - 0
Bartok - 0
Beethoven - 10 (+3)
Bellini - 2
Berg - 0
Berlioz-  2
Biber - 0
Brahms - 3

Boulanger (L.) - 0
Boulez - 5
Caccini - 0
Cage - 10
Carter - 0
Chopin - 2
Corelli - 0
Debussy - 16 (+3)
Dufay - 2 (+2)
Dunstable - 0

Ferrari - 0
Gesualdo - 10
Gluck - 0
Grainger - 2
Hauer - 0
Haydn (J.) - 10 (+2)
Hildegard von Bingen - 0
Ives - 10
Janáček - 0
Koechlin - 3

Crudblud

#9
March 30, 2018, 09:29:26 PM
Bach (CPE) - 3
Bach (JS) - 0
Bartok - 0
Beethoven - 15
Bellini - 2
Berg - 0
Berlioz-  2
Biber - 0
Brahms - 3

Boulanger (L.) - 0
Boulez - 9 (+4)
Caccini - 0
Cage - 12 (+2)
Carter - 0
Chopin - 2
Corelli - 0
Debussy - 21
Dufay - 2
Dunstable - 0

Ferrari - 0
Gesualdo - 12 (+2)
Gluck - 0
Grainger - 2
Hauer - 0
Haydn (J.) - 10
Hildegard von Bingen - 0
Ives - 12 (+2)
Janáček - 0
Koechlin - 3

Sammy

#10
March 31, 2018, 12:51:42 AM
Bach (CPE) - 3
Bach (JS) - 0
Bartok - 0
Beethoven - 20 (+5)
Bellini - 2
Berg - 0
Berlioz-  5 (+3)
Biber - 0
Brahms - 3

Boulanger (L.) - 0
Boulez - 9
Caccini - 0
Cage - 14 (+2)
Carter - 0
Chopin - 2
Corelli - 0
Debussy - 21
Dufay - 2
Dunstable - 0

Ferrari - 0
Gesualdo - 12
Gluck - 0
Grainger - 2
Hauer - 0
Haydn (J.) - 10
Hildegard von Bingen - 0
Ives - 12
Janáček - 0
Koechlin - 3

Marc

#11
March 31, 2018, 01:02:12 AM
Bach (CPE) - 3
Bach (JS) - 5 (+5)
Bartok - 0
Beethoven - 20
Bellini - 2
Berg - 0
Berlioz-  5 
Biber - 0
Brahms - 3

Boulanger (L.) - 0
Boulez - 9
Caccini - 0
Cage - 14 
Carter - 0
Chopin - 4 (+2)
Corelli - 0
Debussy - 21
Dufay - 2
Dunstable - 0

Ferrari - 0
Gesualdo - 12
Gluck - 0
Grainger - 2
Hauer - 0
Haydn (J.) - 10
Hildegard von Bingen - 2 (+2)
Ives - 13 (+1)
Janáček - 0
Koechlin - 3

Cato

#12
March 31, 2018, 02:43:23 AM Last Edit: March 31, 2018, 02:46:00 AM by Cato
Bach (CPE) - 3
Bach (JS) - 5
Bartok - 0
Beethoven - 25 (+5)
Bellini - 2
Berg - 0
Berlioz-  5 
Biber - 0
Brahms - 3

Boulanger (L.) - 0
Boulez - 9
Caccini - 0
Cage - 14 
Carter - 0
Chopin - 4
Corelli - 0
Debussy - 21
Dufay - 2
Dunstable - 0

Ferrari - 0
Gesualdo - 12
Gluck - 0
Grainger - 2
Hauer - 0
Haydn (J.) - 10
Hildegard von Bingen - 2
Ives - 18 (+5)
Janáček - 0
Koechlin - 3


Truly amazing NOT to see Wagner, Scriabin, and Schoenberg here!  0:)
"Meet Miss Ruth Sherwood, from Columbus, Ohio, the Middle of the Universe!"

- Brian Aherne introducing Rosalind Russell in  My Sister Eileen (1942)

amw

#13
March 31, 2018, 02:46:21 AM
gotta rep my guys....

Dunstaple +5
Ferrari +5

Sammy

#14
March 31, 2018, 02:53:32 AM
Quote from: Cato on March 31, 2018, 02:43:23 AMTruly amazing NOT to see Wagner, Scriabin, and Schoenberg here!  0:)

There is a Round Two where those guys will be found.

Sammy

#15
March 31, 2018, 02:58:41 AM
Quote from: amw on March 31, 2018, 02:46:21 AM
gotta rep my guys....

Dunstaple +5
Ferrari +5

I'd love to count your votes, but you need to post them in the same manner as your fellow members.

How to place your votes:

1.  Copy and Paste the most recent voting post.
2.  Delete everything in parentheses.
3.  Assign your points in parentheses.
4.  Make sure to raise the point totals to account for your votes.

San Antone

#16
March 31, 2018, 03:24:38 AM
Bach (CPE) - 3
Bach (JS) - 5
Bartok - 0
Beethoven - 25
Bellini - 2
Berg - 0
Berlioz-  5 
Biber - 0
Brahms - 3

Boulanger (L.) - 0
Boulez - 9
Caccini - 0
Cage - 19  (+5)
Carter - 0
Chopin - 4
Corelli - 0
Debussy - 26 (+5)
Dufay - 2
Dunstable - 0

Ferrari - 0
Gesualdo - 12
Gluck - 0
Grainger - 2
Hauer - 0
Haydn (J.) - 10
Hildegard von Bingen - 2
Ives - 18
Janáček - 0
Koechlin - 3

mc ukrneal

#17
March 31, 2018, 03:44:28 AM
Bach (CPE) - 3
Bach (JS) - 5
Bartok - 0
Beethoven - 30 (+5)
Bellini - 2
Berg - 0
Berlioz-  5 
Biber - 0
Brahms - 3

Boulanger (L.) - 0
Boulez - 9
Caccini - 0
Cage - 19 
Carter - 0
Chopin - 4
Corelli - 0
Debussy - 26
Dufay - 2
Dunstable - 0

Ferrari - 0
Gesualdo - 12
Gluck - 0
Grainger - 2
Hauer - 0
Haydn (J.) - 10
Hildegard von Bingen - 2
Ives - 23 (+5)
Janáček - 0
Koechlin - 3
Be kind to your fellow posters!!

ComposerOfAvantGarde

#18
March 31, 2018, 05:02:16 AM
Bach (CPE) - 3
Bach (JS) - 5
Bartok - 0
Beethoven - 30
Bellini - 2
Berg - 0
Berlioz-  5 
Biber - 0
Brahms - 3

Boulanger (L.) - 0
Boulez - 14 (+5)
Caccini - 0
Cage - 19 
Carter - 0
Chopin - 4
Corelli - 0
Debussy - 26
Dufay - 2
Dunstable - 0

Ferrari - 5 (+5)
Gesualdo - 12
Gluck - 0
Grainger - 2
Hauer - 0
Haydn (J.) - 10
Hildegard von Bingen - 2
Ives - 23
Janáček - 0
Koechlin - 3

André

#19
March 31, 2018, 05:40:37 AM
I'm surprised to see Beethoven get so many votes.  He didn't invent, change or destroy the classical models inherited from Haydn and others before him. Rather brought them farther in terms of their capacity to heighten expression.

Is that being innovative ? Maybe. Since I am no musicologist or trained musician, I can't argue one way or another. Just my two cents, of course  :).
Print
Go Up Pages1 2 3 ... 6
User actions