Composer elimination game

[Don]

   Oh please isn't it obvious,  this poll is headed for a J.S. Bach vs. Beethoven finale which should please Don for the moment. The final result, much like that other Bach vs. Beethoven thread we had earlier will not be to Don's liking I'm afraid.

  marvin

I'll just have to deal with the disappointment.

[Gurn Blanston]

Oh, you bastards! You killed Dvorak!            

Why, I oughtta....



----------------
Now playing:
Haydn 7 last - Vienna PO / Muti - Haydn 7 Last Words for Orchestra pt 4 Sonata III

[BachQ]

Oh, you bastards! You killed Dvorak!            

We feel your pain ......

[Don]

Oh, you bastards! You killed Dvorak!            

Why, I oughtta....

I share your outrage.  What sort of revenge do you recommend?

[Gurn Blanston]

I share your outrage.  What sort of revenge do you recommend?

Mahler is toast!   



----------------
Now playing:
Haydn 7 last - Vienna PO / Muti - Haydn 7 Last Words for Orchestra pt 4 Sonata III

[greg]

Mahler is toast!   



----------------
Now playing:
Haydn 7 last - Vienna PO / Muti - Haydn 7 Last Words for Orchestra pt 4 Sonata III

not really, my vote will just cancel yours out every day, forever 

[Sydney Grew]

J.S. Bach 13
Beethoven 14
Brahms 12
Bruckner 8 + 1 = 9
Chopin 4
Haydn 10
Mahler 10
Mozart 9
Schubert 7
Shostakovich 11 - 1 = 10
Stravinsky 9

[Symphonien]

Can't seem to get rid of Schubert.  Why would anyone still want him on the list?

I don't want him on the list, I was just more interested in getting rid of Dvorak first.

J.S. Bach 13
Beethoven 14
Brahms 12
Bruckner 9
Chopin 4
Haydn 10
Mahler 11 (+)
Mozart 9
Schubert 6 (-)
Shostakovich 10
Stravinsky 9

[Gurn Blanston]

not really, my vote will just cancel yours out every day, forever 

I'll cheat.



----------------
Now playing:
Haydn 7 last - Vienna PO / Muti - Haydn 7 Last Words for Orchestra pt 4 Sonata III

[Gurn Blanston]

I don't want him on the list, I was just more interested in getting rid of Dvorak first.

J.S. Bach 13
Beethoven 14
Brahms 12
Bruckner 9
Chopin 4
Haydn 10
Mahler 11 (+)
Mozart 9
Schubert 6 (-)
Shostakovich 10
Stravinsky 9

J.S. Bach 13
Beethoven 14
Brahms 12
Bruckner 9
Chopin 4
Haydn 10
Mahler 11 - 1 = 10
Mozart 9
Schubert 6 + 1 = 7
Shostakovich 10
Stravinsky 9



----------------
Now playing:
Haydn 7 last - Vienna PO / Muti - Haydn 7 Last Words for Orchestra pt 4 Sonata III

[Symphonien]

J.S. Bach 13
Beethoven 14
Brahms 12
Bruckner 9
Chopin 4
Haydn 10
Mahler 11 - 1 = 10
Mozart 9
Schubert 6 + 1 = 7
Shostakovich 10
Stravinsky 9

Don't worry, I'm sure Greg will be happy to cancel that again.

[J.Z. Herrenberg]

J.S. Bach 13
Beethoven 14 + 1 = 15
Brahms 12
Bruckner 9
Chopin 4
Haydn 10
Mahler 10
Mozart 9
Schubert 7
Shostakovich 10 - 1 = 9
Stravinsky 9

[Siedler]

J.S. Bach 13
Beethoven 15
Brahms 12
Bruckner 9
Chopin 3 -
Haydn 10
Mahler 10
Mozart 9
Schubert 8 +
Shostakovich 9
Stravinsky 9

[Siedler]

I share your outrage.  What sort of revenge do you recommend?

I'd say Chopin. 

[Norbeone]

J.S. Bach 13+1=14
Beethoven 15
Brahms 12
Bruckner 9
Chopin 3
Haydn 10
Mahler 10
Mozart 9
Schubert 8
Shostakovich 9-1=8
Stravinsky 9

[ChamberNut]

Can't seem to get rid of Schubert.  Why would anyone still want him on the list?

  Are you for real?

Don, everyone has their own tastes, on whose music they like best, and whose they like the least.

I, and I'm sure many others here, love Schubert's music a lot!

He's my next favorite after Beethoven and Brahms.  So Schubert gets my (+) vote, thank you very much. 

[springrite]

I don't want him (Schubert) on the list, I was just more interested in getting rid of Dvorak first.

Nah, it was just more convinient at the time. 

J.S. Bach 14
Beethoven 15
Brahms 12
Bruckner 9
Chopin 3
Haydn 10
Mahler 10+1=11
Mozart 9
Schubert 8 -1=7
Shostakovich 8
Stravinsky 9

[btpaul674]

J.S. Bach 14
Beethoven 15
Brahms 12
Bruckner 9
Chopin 3 - 1 = 2
Haydn 10
Mahler 11
Mozart 9
Schubert 7
Shostakovich 8 + 1 = 9
Stravinsky 9

[George]

J.S. Bach 14
Beethoven 15
Brahms 12
Bruckner 9
Chopin 3 +
Haydn 10
Mahler 11
Mozart 9
Schubert 7
Shostakovich 9
Stravinsky 8 -

[orbital]

Let's keep hope alive   

J.S. Bach 14
Beethoven 15
Brahms 12
Bruckner 9
Chopin 3 + 1 = 4
Haydn 10 - 1 = 9
Mahler 11
Mozart 9
Schubert 7
Shostakovich 9
Stravinsky 8