The Symphony Elmination Game

Started by gmstudio, January 13, 2008, 04:15:04 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Print
Go Down Pages 1 2 3 4 5 6
User actions

Marcel

#40
January 17, 2008, 12:51:36 AM
3 - Beethoven - 10
5 - Beethoven - 9
9 - Beethoven - 8
1 - Brahms -  5 -
4 - Brahms -  11
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak -  8
86 - Haydn - 11
102 - Haydn - 10
5 - Mahler  - 10
9 - Mahler - 18
3 - Mendelssohn -  9
40 - Mozart - 10
41 - Mozart - 9
9 - Schubert - 6 -
5 - Shostakovich  - 8
2 - Sibelius - 12 +
5 - Sibelius - 11

val

#41
January 17, 2008, 01:21:42 AM

3 - Beethoven - 10 + 1 = 11
5 - Beethoven - 9
9 - Beethoven - 8
1 - Brahms -  5
4 - Brahms -  11
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak -  8
86 - Haydn - 11
102 - Haydn - 10
5 - Mahler  - 10
9 - Mahler - 18-1 = 17
3 - Mendelssohn -  9
40 - Mozart - 10
41 - Mozart - 9
9 - Schubert 6
5 - Shostakovich  - 8
2 - Sibelius - 12
5 - Sibelius - 11-1 = 10

Symphonien

#42
January 17, 2008, 06:35:29 AM
3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 9
9 - Beethoven - 8
1 - Brahms -  5
4 - Brahms -  11
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak -  8
86 - Haydn - 9 (--)
102 - Haydn - 10
5 - Mahler  - 10
9 - Mahler - 18 (+)
3 - Mendelssohn -  9
40 - Mozart - 10
41 - Mozart - 9
9 - Schubert 6
5 - Shostakovich  - 8
2 - Sibelius - 12
5 - Sibelius - 10

btpaul674

#43
January 17, 2008, 11:06:45 AM
3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 9
9 - Beethoven - 8
1 - Brahms -  5
4 - Brahms -  11
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak -  8
86 - Haydn - 7 (--)
102 - Haydn - 10
5 - Mahler  - 10
9 - Mahler - 18
3 - Mendelssohn -  9
40 - Mozart - 10
41 - Mozart - 9
9 - Schubert 6
5 - Shostakovich  - 8
2 - Sibelius - 12
5 - Sibelius - 11 (+)

hornteacher

#44
January 17, 2008, 02:52:47 PM
3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 9
9 - Beethoven - 8
1 - Brahms -  5
4 - Brahms -  11
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak -  9 (+)
86 - Haydn - 7
102 - Haydn - 10
5 - Mahler  - 10
9 - Mahler - 16 (--)
3 - Mendelssohn -  9
40 - Mozart - 10
41 - Mozart - 9
9 - Schubert 6
5 - Shostakovich  - 8
2 - Sibelius - 12
5 - Sibelius - 11

Lethevich

#45
January 17, 2008, 04:23:43 PM
3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 9
9 - Beethoven - 8
1 - Brahms -  5
4 - Brahms -  11
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak -  9
86 - Haydn - 8 +
102 - Haydn - 10
5 - Mahler  - 10
9 - Mahler - 14 --
3 - Mendelssohn -  9
40 - Mozart - 10
41 - Mozart - 9
9 - Schubert 6
5 - Shostakovich  - 8
2 - Sibelius - 12
5 - Sibelius - 11
Peanut butter, flour and sugar do not make cookies. They make FIRE.

Lilas Pastia

#46
January 17, 2008, 06:07:06 PM Last Edit: January 17, 2008, 06:10:51 PM by Lilas Pastia
3 - Beethoven - 10
5 - Beethoven - 10
9 - Beethoven - 10
1 - Brahms - 10
4 - Brahms - 10
9 - Bruckner  10+1= 11
9 - Dvorak - 10
45 - Haydn - 10
86 - Haydn - 10
102 - Haydn - 10
5 - Mahler  - 10
9 - Mahler - 14-2=12
3 - Mendelssohn - 10-1=9
37 - Mozart -  9 Mozart 37??? This one is asking for it! 9-1=8
40 - Mozart - 10
41 - Mozart -  9
9 - Schubert - 10
5 - Shostakovich  - 10
2 - Sibelius - 10
5 - Sibelius - 10

May I point out the cardinal flaw of this survey? Everybody gives points to their favourite symphony and takes away from its closest "rival". I predict that in the end the most points will remain with the underdogs: those that are still at 10... And may I point out that a nonexistent symphony has more points  than Beethoven's 9th... ??? ??? ::)

val

#47
January 18, 2008, 01:54:19 AM

3 - Beethoven - 10 + 1 = 11
5 - Beethoven - 10
9 - Beethoven - 10
1 - Brahms - 10
4 - Brahms - 10
9 - Bruckner  10+1= 11
9 - Dvorak - 10
45 - Haydn - 10
86 - Haydn - 10
102 - Haydn - 10
5 - Mahler  - 10
9 - Mahler - 14-2=12
3 - Mendelssohn - 10-1=9
37 - Mozart -  8
40 - Mozart - 10
41 - Mozart -  9
9 - Schubert - 10
5 - Shostakovich  - 10 - 2 = 8
2 - Sibelius - 10
5 - Sibelius - 10

Symphonien

#48
January 18, 2008, 02:12:59 AM
Lilas Pastia quoted an old post...

not edward

#49
January 18, 2008, 03:32:29 AM
Quote from: Symphonien on January 18, 2008, 02:12:59 AM
Lilas Pastia quoted an old post...
That would be a good way to sabotage these threads: have several people quoting old posts. Hmm. ;)
"I don't at all mind actively disliking a piece of contemporary music, but in order to feel happy about it I must consciously understand why I dislike it. Otherwise it remains in my mind as unfinished business."
-- Aaron Copland, The Pleasures of Music

Symphonien

#50
January 18, 2008, 04:57:44 AM
Quote from: edward on January 18, 2008, 03:32:29 AM
That would be a good way to sabotage these threads: have several people quoting old posts. Hmm. ;)
I'm shocked that you would even consider such atrocities edward! ;D

Anyway, I'll take it from Lethe since Lilas and val didn't seem to do it properly.

3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 9
9 - Beethoven - 8
1 - Brahms -  5
4 - Brahms -  11
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak -  9
86 - Haydn - 6 (--)
102 - Haydn - 10
5 - Mahler  - 10
9 - Mahler - 16 (+)
3 - Mendelssohn - 9
40 - Mozart - 10
41 - Mozart - 9
9 - Schubert 6
5 - Shostakovich  - 8
2 - Sibelius - 12
5 - Sibelius - 11

gmstudio

#51
January 18, 2008, 06:41:39 AM
3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 9
9 - Beethoven - 8
1 - Brahms -  5 - 1 = 4
4 - Brahms -  11
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak -  9
86 - Haydn - 6
102 - Haydn - 10
5 - Mahler  - 10
9 - Mahler - 16 + 1 = 17
3 - Mendelssohn - 9
40 - Mozart - 10
41 - Mozart - 9
9 - Schubert 6 - 1 = 5
5 - Shostakovich  - 8
2 - Sibelius - 12
5 - Sibelius - 11


The Mozart 37 was a typo on my part. Now that it's gone I'm considering it a non-issue.

hornteacher

#52
January 18, 2008, 04:13:03 PM
3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 9
9 - Beethoven - 9 (+)
1 - Brahms -  4
4 - Brahms -  11
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak -  9
86 - Haydn - 6
102 - Haydn - 10
5 - Mahler  - 10
9 - Mahler - 15 (--)
3 - Mendelssohn - 9
40 - Mozart - 10
41 - Mozart - 9
9 - Schubert 5
5 - Shostakovich  - 8
2 - Sibelius - 12
5 - Sibelius - 11

Lethevich

#53
January 18, 2008, 04:36:12 PM
3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 9
9 - Beethoven - 9
1 - Brahms -  5 +
4 - Brahms -  11
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak -  9
86 - Haydn - 6
102 - Haydn - 10
5 - Mahler  - 10
9 - Mahler - 13 --
3 - Mendelssohn - 9
40 - Mozart - 10
41 - Mozart - 9
9 - Schubert 5
5 - Shostakovich  - 8
2 - Sibelius - 12
5 - Sibelius - 11
Peanut butter, flour and sugar do not make cookies. They make FIRE.

val

#54
January 19, 2008, 01:30:03 AM

3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 9
9 - Beethoven - 9
1 - Brahms -  5
4 - Brahms -  11
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak -  9
86 - Haydn - 6
102 - Haydn - 10
5 - Mahler  - 10 - 1 = 9
9 - Mahler - 13
3 - Mendelssohn - 9
40 - Mozart - 10
41 - Mozart - 9
9 - Schubert 5 + 1 = 6
5 - Shostakovich  - 8
2 - Sibelius - 12
5 - Sibelius - 11 - 1 = 10

Symphonien

#55
January 19, 2008, 05:44:06 AM
3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 9
9 - Beethoven - 9
1 - Brahms -  5
4 - Brahms -  11
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak -  9
86 - Haydn - 6
102 - Haydn - 10
5 - Mahler  - 10 (+)
9 - Mahler - 13
3 - Mendelssohn - 9
40 - Mozart - 10
41 - Mozart - 9
9 - Schubert - 6
5 - Shostakovich - 8
2 - Sibelius - 10 (--)
5 - Sibelius - 10

btpaul674

#56
January 19, 2008, 05:59:10 AM

3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 9
9 - Beethoven - 9
1 - Brahms -  5
4 - Brahms -  11
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak -  9
86 - Haydn - 4 (--)
102 - Haydn - 10
5 - Mahler  - 10
9 - Mahler - 13
3 - Mendelssohn - 9
40 - Mozart - 10
41 - Mozart - 9
9 - Schubert - 6
5 - Shostakovich - 8
2 - Sibelius - 10
5 - Sibelius - 11 (+)

hornteacher

#57
January 19, 2008, 10:32:33 AM
3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 9
9 - Beethoven - 9
1 - Brahms -  5
4 - Brahms -  11
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak -  10 (+)
86 - Haydn - 4
102 - Haydn - 10
5 - Mahler  - 10
9 - Mahler - 11 (--)
3 - Mendelssohn - 9
40 - Mozart - 10
41 - Mozart - 9
9 - Schubert - 6
5 - Shostakovich - 8
2 - Sibelius - 10
5 - Sibelius - 11

gmstudio

#58
January 19, 2008, 04:55:28 PM
3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 9
9 - Beethoven - 9
1 - Brahms -  4 -
4 - Brahms -  11
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak -  10
86 - Haydn - 3 -
102 - Haydn - 10
5 - Mahler  - 10
9 - Mahler - 12 +
3 - Mendelssohn - 9
40 - Mozart - 10
41 - Mozart - 9
9 - Schubert - 6
5 - Shostakovich - 8
2 - Sibelius - 10
5 - Sibelius - 11

Lethevich

#59
January 19, 2008, 11:19:28 PM
3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 9
9 - Beethoven - 9
1 - Brahms -  4
4 - Brahms -  11
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak -  10
86 - Haydn - 3
102 - Haydn - 11 +
5 - Mahler  - 10
9 - Mahler - 10 --
3 - Mendelssohn - 9
40 - Mozart - 10
41 - Mozart - 9
9 - Schubert - 6
5 - Shostakovich - 8
2 - Sibelius - 10
5 - Sibelius - 11
Peanut butter, flour and sugar do not make cookies. They make FIRE.
Print
Go Up Pages 1 2 3 4 5 6
User actions