The Symphony Elmination Game

Started by gmstudio, January 13, 2008, 04:15:04 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Print
Go Down Pages 1 ... 3 4 5 6
User actions

btpaul674

#80
January 23, 2008, 08:23:07 PM
3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 10
9 - Beethoven - 10
1 - Brahms -  6
4 - Brahms -  10
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak - 11
102 - Haydn - 10
5 - Mahler  - 10
9 - Mahler - 1
3 - Mendelssohn - 9
40 - Mozart - 9
41 - Mozart - 8
9 - Schubert - 6
5 - Shostakovich - 0 (--)
2 - Sibelius - 8
5 - Sibelius - 12 (+)

couldn't bring myself to take out mahler...

but i've heard shosty's 5th enough to where i am no so attracted to it.

val

#81
January 23, 2008, 11:34:11 PM

3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 10
9 - Beethoven - 10
1 - Brahms -  6
4 - Brahms -  10
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak - 11
102 - Haydn - 10
5 - Mahler  - 10
9 - Mahler - 1 + 2 = 3
3 - Mendelssohn - 9
40 - Mozart - 9
41 - Mozart - 8
9 - Schubert - 6
2 - Sibelius - 8
5 - Sibelius - 12 -2 =10


from the new world

#82
January 24, 2008, 12:44:10 AM Last Edit: January 24, 2008, 09:19:07 AM by from the new world
3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 10
9 - Beethoven - 10
1 - Brahms -  6
4 - Brahms -  10
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak - 11
102 - Haydn - 10
5 - Mahler  - 10
9 - Mahler - 4 (+)
3 - Mendelssohn - 9
40 - Mozart - 9
41 - Mozart - 7 (-)
9 - Schubert - 5 (-)
2 - Sibelius - 8
5 - Sibelius - 10

gmstudio

#83
January 24, 2008, 05:09:21 AM
3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 10
9 - Beethoven - 10
1 - Brahms -  5 (-)
4 - Brahms -  10
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak - 11
102 - Haydn - 10
5 - Mahler  - 10
9 - Mahler - 5 (+)
3 - Mendelssohn - 9
40 - Mozart - 9
41 - Mozart - 7
9 - Schubert - 4 (-)
2 - Sibelius - 8
5 - Sibelius - 10

hornteacher

#84
January 24, 2008, 03:55:53 PM

3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 10
9 - Beethoven - 11 (+)
1 - Brahms -  5
4 - Brahms -  10
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak - 11
102 - Haydn - 10
5 - Mahler  - 10
9 - Mahler - 2 (---) Correction from Post #81 (too many points added).
3 - Mendelssohn - 9
40 - Mozart - 9
41 - Mozart - 7
9 - Schubert - 4
2 - Sibelius - 8
5 - Sibelius - 10

orbital

#85
January 24, 2008, 05:22:55 PM Last Edit: January 24, 2008, 05:26:02 PM by orbital
3 - Beethoven - 11
5 -  Beethoven - 10 + 1 = 11
9 - Beethoven - 11
1 - Brahms -  5
4 - Brahms -  10
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak - 11
102 - Haydn - 10
5 - Mahler  - 10
9 - Mahler - 0 (-2)  This happened with Mahler before. He is punished  for fraud >:D
3 - Mendelssohn - 9
40 - Mozart - 9
41 - Mozart - 7
9 - Schubert - 4
2 - Sibelius - 8
5 - Sibelius - 10

gmstudio

#86
January 24, 2008, 05:52:22 PM
Well, the greatest symphony ever written was just eliminated. That's a shame.

Guess we'll have to keep playing to find the runner up.  ;D

anasazi

#87
January 25, 2008, 04:39:29 AM
3 - Beethoven - 11
9 - Beethoven - 11
1 - Brahms -  5 + 1 = 6
4 - Brahms -  10
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak - 11 - 1 = 10
102 - Haydn - 10 -1 = 9
5 - Mahler  - 10
3 - Mendelssohn - 9
40 - Mozart - 9
41 - Mozart - 7
9 - Schubert - 4
2 - Sibelius - 8
5 - Sibelius - 10

Rod Corkin

#88
January 25, 2008, 05:31:48 AM


;D
"If I were but of noble birth..." - Rod Corkin
https://www.tapatalk.com/groups/classicalmusicmayhem/

gmstudio

#89
January 25, 2008, 09:08:53 AM
3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 11
9 - Beethoven - 12 (+)
1 - Brahms -  6
4 - Brahms -  10
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak - 10
102 - Haydn - 9
5 - Mahler  - 10
3 - Mendelssohn - 9
40 - Mozart - 9
41 - Mozart - 7
9 - Schubert - 2  (--)
2 - Sibelius - 8
5 - Sibelius - 10

val

#90
January 26, 2008, 01:14:30 AM

3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 11
9 - Beethoven - 12
1 - Brahms -  6
4 - Brahms -  10
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak - 10
102 - Haydn - 9
5 - Mahler  - 10
3 - Mendelssohn - 9
40 - Mozart - 9
41 - Mozart - 7
9 - Schubert - 2 + 1 = 3 
2 - Sibelius - 8
5 - Sibelius - 10 - 2 = 8

Marcel

#91
January 26, 2008, 12:17:52 PM
3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 11
9 - Beethoven - 13
1 - Brahms -  6
4 - Brahms -  10
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak - 10
102 - Haydn - 9
5 - Mahler  - 10
3 - Mendelssohn - 9
40 - Mozart - 9
41 - Mozart - 7
9 - Schubert - 1 -
2 - Sibelius - 8
5 - Sibelius - 8

gmstudio

#92
January 26, 2008, 12:36:58 PM
3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 11
9 - Beethoven - 13
1 - Brahms -  5 -
4 - Brahms -  10
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak - 10
102 - Haydn - 9
5 - Mahler  - 11 +
3 - Mendelssohn - 9
40 - Mozart - 9
41 - Mozart - 7
9 - Schubert - 0 -
2 - Sibelius - 8
5 - Sibelius - 8

rappy

#93
January 26, 2008, 12:48:09 PM Last Edit: January 27, 2008, 05:07:48 AM by rappy
3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 11
9 - Beethoven - 13
1 - Brahms -  5 + 1 = 6
4 - Brahms -  10
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak - 10 - 1 = 9
102 - Haydn - 9
5 - Mahler  - 11
3 - Mendelssohn - 9
40 - Mozart - 9
41 - Mozart - 7
2 - Sibelius - 8 - 1 = 7
5 - Sibelius - 8

Where is Prokofiev on that list?

hornteacher

#94
January 26, 2008, 03:54:13 PM
3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 11
9 - Beethoven - 13
1 - Brahms -  6
4 - Brahms -  10
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak - 10 (+)
102 - Haydn - 9
5 - Mahler  - 9 (--)
3 - Mendelssohn - 9
40 - Mozart - 9
41 - Mozart - 7
2 - Sibelius - 7
5 - Sibelius - 8

from the new world

#95
January 27, 2008, 01:18:03 PM
3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 11
9 - Beethoven - 13
1 - Brahms -  6
4 - Brahms -  10
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak - 8 (--)
102 - Haydn - 9
5 - Mahler  - 10 (+)
3 - Mendelssohn - 9
40 - Mozart - 9
41 - Mozart - 7
2 - Sibelius - 7
5 - Sibelius - 8

anasazi

#96
January 27, 2008, 03:29:50 PM
3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 11
9 - Beethoven - 13
1 - Brahms -  7 (+)
4 - Brahms -  10
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak - 8
102 - Haydn - 9
5 - Mahler  - 9 (-)
3 - Mendelssohn - 9
40 - Mozart - 9
41 - Mozart - 7
2 - Sibelius - 6 (-)
5 - Sibelius - 8

hornteacher

#97
January 27, 2008, 05:40:30 PM
3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 11
9 - Beethoven - 13
1 - Brahms -  7
4 - Brahms -  10
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak - 9 (+)
102 - Haydn - 9
5 - Mahler  - 7 (--)
3 - Mendelssohn - 9
40 - Mozart - 9
41 - Mozart - 7
2 - Sibelius - 6
5 - Sibelius - 8

val

#98
January 28, 2008, 12:40:15 AM

3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 11
9 - Beethoven - 13
1 - Brahms -  7
4 - Brahms -  10
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak - 9
102 - Haydn - 9
5 - Mahler  - 7 - 1 = 6
3 - Mendelssohn - 9
40 - Mozart - 9
41 - Mozart - 7 + 1 = 8
2 - Sibelius - 6
5 - Sibelius - 8 - 1 = 7

from the new world

#99
January 28, 2008, 01:38:21 AM
3 - Beethoven - 11
5 - Beethoven - 11
9 - Beethoven - 13
1 - Brahms -  7
4 - Brahms -  10
9 - Bruckner  - 10
9 - Dvorak - 7 (--)
102 - Haydn - 9
5 - Mahler  - 7 (+)
3 - Mendelssohn - 9
40 - Mozart - 9
41 - Mozart - 8
2 - Sibelius - 6
5 - Sibelius - 7
Print
Go Up Pages 1 ... 3 4 5 6
User actions