Text only | Text with Images

GMG Classical Music Forum

The Music Room => General Classical Music Discussion => The Polling Station => Topic started by: Sammy on April 16, 2018, 09:29:55 AM

Title: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Sammy on April 16, 2018, 09:29:55 AM
After two qualifying rounds, we have arrived at the finale of our Innovative Composer Game.  There are 20 composers for our voting consideration, and the 5 having the highest scores will be duly recognized.

Voting Rules:

1.  You may vote once daily.

2.  When you vote, you will have 10 upward points to distribute as you wish except that no composer may receive more than 5 points.

3.  Our game ends with the first composer to reach 100 points.

4.  The Half-Time Adjustment is in effect.  With the first composer to garner 50 points, the 7 composers having the lowest scores will be eliminated from the game; this number could rise if there are ties toward the bottom of the board.

Let's Cast Votes:

Bach (CPE) - 0
Beethoven - 3 (+3)
Boulez - 0
Cage - 0
Chopin - 0

Debussy - 0
Gesualdo - 0
Haydn - 0
Ives - 0
Janáček - 0

Liszt - 0
Machaut - 0
Mahler - 0
Monteverdi - 0
Mozart - 0

Schoenberg - 5 (+5)
Scriabin - 0
Sibelius - 0
Stravinsky - 0
Wagner - 2 (+2)
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Gurn Blanston on April 16, 2018, 10:04:45 AM
Bach (CPE) - 5 (+5)
Beethoven - 3
Boulez - 0
Cage - 0
Chopin - 0

Debussy - 0
Gesualdo - 0
Haydn - 5  (+5)
Ives - 0
Janáček - 0

Liszt - 0
Machaut - 0
Mahler - 0
Monteverdi - 0
Mozart - 0

Schoenberg - 5
Scriabin - 0
Sibelius - 0
Stravinsky - 0
Wagner - 2
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: mc ukrneal on April 16, 2018, 10:14:08 AM
Bach (CPE) - 5 (+5)
Beethoven - 3
Boulez - 0
Cage - 0
Chopin - 0

Debussy - 0
Gesualdo - 0
Haydn - 5  (+5)
Ives - 5 (+5)
Janáček - 0

Liszt - 0
Machaut - 0
Mahler - 0
Monteverdi - 5 (+5)
Mozart - 0

Schoenberg - 5
Scriabin - 0
Sibelius - 0
Stravinsky - 0
Wagner - 2
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: André on April 16, 2018, 10:16:25 AM
Bach (CPE) - 5
Beethoven - 4
Boulez - 0
Cage - 0
Chopin - 0

Debussy - 0
Gesualdo - 0
Haydn - 7 (+2)
Ives - 5
Janáček - 0

Liszt - 0
Machaut - 0
Mahler - 0
Monteverdi - 5
Mozart - 0

Schoenberg - 7 (+2)
Scriabin - 0
Sibelius - 3 (+3)
Stravinsky - 0
Wagner - 5 (+3)
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Crudblud on April 16, 2018, 10:36:18 AM
Bach (CPE) - 5
Beethoven - 4
Boulez - 2 (+2)
Cage - 2 (+2)
Chopin - 0

Debussy - 0
Gesualdo - 0
Haydn - 7
Ives - 8 (+3)
Janáček - 0

Liszt - 0
Machaut - 0
Mahler - 3 (+3)
Monteverdi - 5
Mozart - 0

Schoenberg - 7
Scriabin - 0
Sibelius - 3
Stravinsky - 0
Wagner - 5
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: San Antone on April 16, 2018, 10:46:51 AM
Bach (CPE) - 5
Beethoven - 4
Boulez - 2
Cage - 4 (+2)
Chopin - 0

Debussy - 4 (+4)
Gesualdo - 0
Haydn - 7
Ives - 8
Janáček - 0

Liszt - 4 (+4)
Machaut - 0
Mahler - 3
Monteverdi - 5
Mozart - 0

Schoenberg - 7
Scriabin - 0
Sibelius - 3
Stravinsky - 0
Wagner - 5
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: North Star on April 16, 2018, 12:26:44 PM
Bach (CPE) - 5
Beethoven - 4
Boulez - 2
Cage - 4
Chopin - 5 (+5)

Debussy - 4
Gesualdo - 0
Haydn - 7
Ives - 8
Janáček - 0

Liszt - 4
Machaut - 0
Mahler - 3
Monteverdi - 5
Mozart - 0

Schoenberg - 7
Scriabin - 0
Sibelius - 8 (+5)
Stravinsky - 0
Wagner - 5
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Cato on April 16, 2018, 12:40:30 PM
Bach (CPE) - 5
Beethoven - 4
Boulez - 2
Cage - 4
Chopin - 5

Debussy - 4
Gesualdo - 5 (+5)
Haydn - 7
Ives - 8
Janáček - 0

Liszt - 4
Machaut - 0
Mahler - 3
Monteverdi - 5
Mozart - 0

Schoenberg - 7
Scriabin - 5 (+5)
Sibelius - 8
Stravinsky - 0
Wagner - 5
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: ComposerOfAvantGarde on April 16, 2018, 04:00:58 PM
Bach (CPE) - 5
Beethoven - 4
Boulez - 7 (+5)
Cage - 4
Chopin - 5

Debussy - 4
Gesualdo - 5
Haydn - 7
Ives - 8
Janáček - 0

Liszt - 4
Machaut - 0
Mahler - 3
Monteverdi - 5
Mozart - 5 (+5)

Schoenberg - 7
Scriabin - 5
Sibelius - 8
Stravinsky - 0
Wagner - 5
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: amw on April 16, 2018, 07:33:16 PM
Bach (CPE) - 5
Beethoven - 4
Boulez - 7
Cage - 9 (+5)
Chopin - 5

Debussy - 4
Gesualdo - 5
Haydn - 7
Ives - 8
Janáček - 0

Liszt - 4
Machaut - 5 (+5)
Mahler - 3
Monteverdi - 5
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 7
Scriabin - 5
Sibelius - 8
Stravinsky - 0
Wagner - 5
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: GioCar on April 16, 2018, 08:07:09 PM
Bach (CPE) - 5
Beethoven - 7 (+3)
Boulez - 7
Cage - 9
Chopin - 5

Debussy - 4
Gesualdo - 5
Haydn - 7
Ives - 8
Janáček - 0

Liszt - 4
Machaut - 5
Mahler - 3
Monteverdi - 7 (+2)
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 7
Scriabin - 5
Sibelius - 8
Stravinsky - 0
Wagner - 10 (+5)
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Sammy on April 16, 2018, 11:09:28 PM
Bach (CPE) - 5
Beethoven - 10 (+3)
Boulez - 7
Cage - 9
Chopin - 5

Debussy - 4
Gesualdo - 5
Haydn - 7
Ives - 8
Janáček - 0

Liszt - 4
Machaut - 5
Mahler - 3
Monteverdi - 7
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 12 (+5)
Scriabin - 5
Sibelius - 8
Stravinsky - 0
Wagner - 12 (+2)
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: André on April 17, 2018, 03:39:48 AM

Bach (CPE) - 7 (+2)
Beethoven - 10
Boulez - 7
Cage - 9
Chopin - 5

Debussy - 4
Gesualdo - 5
Haydn - 7
Ives - 8
Janáček - 0

Liszt - 4
Machaut - 5
Mahler - 8 (+5)
Monteverdi - 7
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 12
Scriabin - 5
Sibelius - 8
Stravinsky - 0
Wagner - 15 (+3)
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: San Antone on April 17, 2018, 03:42:44 AM
Bach (CPE) - 7
Beethoven - 10
Boulez - 7
Cage - 11 (+2)
Chopin - 5

Debussy - 8 (+4)
Gesualdo - 5
Haydn - 7
Ives - 8
Janáček - 0

Liszt - 8 (+4)
Machaut - 5
Mahler - 8
Monteverdi - 7
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 12
Scriabin - 5
Sibelius - 8
Stravinsky - 0
Wagner - 15
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Cato on April 17, 2018, 04:11:46 AM
Bach (CPE) - 7
Beethoven - 10
Boulez - 7
Cage - 11
Chopin - 5

Debussy - 8
Gesualdo - 10 (+5)
Haydn - 7
Ives - 8
Janáček - 0

Liszt - 8
Machaut - 5
Mahler - 8
Monteverdi - 7
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 12
Scriabin - 10 (+5)
Sibelius - 8
Stravinsky - 0
Wagner - 15
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Florestan on April 17, 2018, 04:22:25 AM
Bach (CPE) - 12 (+5)
Beethoven - 10
Boulez - 7
Cage - 11
Chopin - 5

Debussy - 8
Gesualdo - 10
Haydn - 7
Ives - 8
Janáček - 0

Liszt - 13 (+5)
Machaut - 5
Mahler - 8
Monteverdi - 7
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 12
Scriabin - 10
Sibelius - 8
Stravinsky - 0
Wagner - 15
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: mc ukrneal on April 17, 2018, 04:43:45 AM
Bach (CPE) - 12
Beethoven - 10
Boulez - 7
Cage - 11
Chopin - 5

Debussy - 8
Gesualdo - 10
Haydn - 7
Ives - 13 (+5)
Janáček - 0

Liszt - 13
Machaut - 5
Mahler - 8
Monteverdi - 12 (+5)
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 12
Scriabin - 10
Sibelius - 8
Stravinsky - 0
Wagner - 15
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Crudblud on April 17, 2018, 05:41:50 AM
Bach (CPE) - 12
Beethoven - 10
Boulez - 7
Cage - 11
Chopin - 5

Debussy - 8
Gesualdo - 10
Haydn - 7
Ives - 13
Janáček - 0

Liszt - 13
Machaut - 5
Mahler - 13 (+5)
Monteverdi - 12
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 12
Scriabin - 10
Sibelius - 8
Stravinsky - 5 (+5)
Wagner - 15
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Ken B on April 17, 2018, 05:43:15 AM
Quote from: mc ukrneal on April 17, 2018, 04:43:45 AM
Bach (CPE) - 12
Beethoven - 10
Boulez - 7
Cage - 11
Chopin - 5

Debussy - 8
Gesualdo - 10
Haydn - 7
Ives - 13
Janáček - 0

Liszt - 13
Machaut - 5
Mahler - 8
Monteverdi - 17 (+5)
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 12
Scriabin - 10
Sibelius - 8
Stravinsky - 5 (+5)
Wagner - 15
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Sammy on April 17, 2018, 08:14:21 AM
Replies 17 and 18 crashed.

Corrected Board:

Bach (CPE) - 12
Beethoven - 10
Boulez - 7
Cage - 11
Chopin - 5

Debussy - 8
Gesualdo - 10
Haydn - 7
Ives - 13
Janáček - 0

Liszt - 13
Machaut - 5
Mahler - 13
Monteverdi - 17
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 12
Scriabin - 10
Sibelius - 8
Stravinsky - 10
Wagner - 15
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: ComposerOfAvantGarde on April 17, 2018, 03:10:34 PM


Bach (CPE) - 12
Beethoven - 10
Boulez - 12 (+5)
Cage - 11
Chopin - 5

Debussy - 8
Gesualdo - 10
Haydn - 7
Ives - 13
Janáček - 0

Liszt - 13
Machaut - 5
Mahler - 13
Monteverdi - 17
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 12
Scriabin - 10
Sibelius - 8
Stravinsky - 10
Wagner - 20 (+5)
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Ken B on April 17, 2018, 03:16:11 PM


Bach (CPE) - 12
Beethoven - 10
Boulez - 12
Cage - 11
Chopin - 5

Debussy - 8
Gesualdo - 10
Haydn - 7
Ives - 13
Janáček - 0

Liszt - 13
Machaut - 5
Mahler - 13
Monteverdi - 22(+5)
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 12
Scriabin - 10
Sibelius - 8
Stravinsky - 13(+3)
Wagner - 22(+2)
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: amw on April 17, 2018, 07:51:34 PM
Bach (CPE) - 12
Beethoven - 10
Boulez - 7
Cage - 11
Chopin - 5

Debussy - 8
Gesualdo - 10
Haydn - 9 (+2)
Ives - 13
Janáček - 5 (+5)

Liszt - 13
Machaut - 8 (+3)
Mahler - 13
Monteverdi - 17
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 12
Scriabin - 10
Sibelius - 8
Stravinsky - 10
Wagner - 15
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Crudblud on April 17, 2018, 09:30:39 PM
Bach (CPE) - 12
Beethoven - 10
Boulez - 12 (+5)
Cage - 11
Chopin - 5

Debussy - 8
Gesualdo - 10
Haydn - 9
Ives - 13
Janáček - 5

Liszt - 13
Machaut - 8
Mahler - 13
Monteverdi - 17
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 12
Scriabin - 10
Sibelius - 8
Stravinsky - 15 (+5)
Wagner - 15
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: mc ukrneal on April 17, 2018, 10:44:59 PM
Bach (CPE) - 12
Beethoven - 10
Boulez - 12
Cage - 11
Chopin - 5

Debussy - 8
Gesualdo - 10
Haydn - 9
Ives - 18 (+5)
Janáček - 5

Liszt - 13
Machaut - 8
Mahler - 13
Monteverdi - 22 (+5)
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 12
Scriabin - 10
Sibelius - 8
Stravinsky - 15
Wagner - 15
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Sammy on April 17, 2018, 11:21:47 PM
Reply no. 22 has some wrong numbers.

Corrected Board:

Bach (CPE) - 12
Beethoven - 10
Boulez - 17
Cage - 11
Chopin - 5

Debussy - 8
Gesualdo - 10
Haydn - 9
Ives - 18
Janáček - 5

Liszt - 13
Machaut - 8
Mahler - 13
Monteverdi - 27
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 12
Scriabin - 10
Sibelius - 8
Stravinsky - 18
Wagner - 22
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Sammy on April 17, 2018, 11:23:21 PM
Bach (CPE) - 12
Beethoven - 10
Boulez - 17
Cage - 11
Chopin - 5

Debussy - 8
Gesualdo - 10
Haydn - 9
Ives - 18
Janáček - 5

Liszt - 13
Machaut - 8
Mahler - 13
Monteverdi - 27
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 17 (+5)
Scriabin - 10
Sibelius - 8
Stravinsky - 18
Wagner - 27 (+5)
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: San Antone on April 18, 2018, 01:24:54 AM
Bach (CPE) - 12
Beethoven - 10
Boulez - 17
Cage - 13 (+2)
Chopin - 5

Debussy - 12 (+4)
Gesualdo - 10
Haydn - 9
Ives - 18
Janáček - 5

Liszt - 17 (+4)
Machaut - 8
Mahler - 13
Monteverdi - 27
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 17
Scriabin - 10
Sibelius - 8
Stravinsky - 18
Wagner - 27
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: North Star on April 18, 2018, 01:35:46 AM
Bach (CPE) - 12
Beethoven - 10
Boulez - 17
Cage - 13
Chopin - 10 (+5)

Debussy - 12
Gesualdo - 10
Haydn - 9
Ives - 18
Janáček - 8 (+3)

Liszt - 17
Machaut - 8
Mahler - 13
Monteverdi - 27
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 17
Scriabin - 10
Sibelius - 10 (+2)
Stravinsky - 18
Wagner - 27
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Florestan on April 18, 2018, 02:08:18 AM
Bach (CPE) - 17 (+5)
Beethoven - 10
Boulez - 17
Cage - 13
Chopin - 10

Debussy - 12
Gesualdo - 10
Haydn - 9
Ives - 18
Janáček - 8

Liszt - 17
Machaut - 8
Mahler - 13
Monteverdi - 32 (+5)
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 17
Scriabin - 10
Sibelius - 10
Stravinsky - 18
Wagner - 27
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Cato on April 18, 2018, 03:13:40 AM
Bach (CPE) - 17
Beethoven - 10
Boulez - 17
Cage - 13
Chopin - 10

Debussy - 12
Gesualdo - 15 (+5)
Haydn - 9
Ives - 18
Janáček - 8

Liszt - 17
Machaut - 8
Mahler - 13
Monteverdi - 32
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 17
Scriabin - 15 (+5)
Sibelius - 10
Stravinsky - 18
Wagner - 27
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: André on April 18, 2018, 06:08:30 AM

Bach (CPE) - 17
Beethoven - 10
Boulez - 17
Cage - 13
Chopin - 10

Debussy - 12
Gesualdo - 15
Haydn - 14 (+5)
Ives - 18
Janáček - 8

Liszt - 17
Machaut - 8
Mahler - 13
Monteverdi - 32
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 17
Scriabin - 15
Sibelius - 10
Stravinsky - 18
Wagner - 32 (+5)
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Ken B on April 18, 2018, 07:25:59 AM

Bach (CPE) - 17
Beethoven - 10
Boulez - 17
Cage - 13
Chopin - 10

Debussy - 12
Gesualdo - 15
Haydn - 14
Ives - 18
Janáček - 8

Liszt - 17
Machaut - 8
Mahler - 13
Monteverdi - 37(+5)
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 17
Scriabin - 15
Sibelius - 10
Stravinsky - 23(+5)
Wagner - 32
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Mahlerian on April 18, 2018, 08:07:39 AM
Bach (CPE) - 17
Beethoven - 10
Boulez - 17
Cage - 13
Chopin - 10

Debussy - 17 (+5)
Gesualdo - 15
Haydn - 14
Ives - 18
Janáček - 8

Liszt - 17
Machaut - 8
Mahler - 18 (+5)
Monteverdi - 37
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 17
Scriabin - 15
Sibelius - 10
Stravinsky - 23
Wagner - 32
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Sergeant Rock on April 18, 2018, 08:36:29 AM

Bach (CPE) - 17
Beethoven - 10
Boulez - 17
Cage - 13
Chopin - 10

Debussy - 17
Gesualdo - 15
Haydn - 14
Ives - 18
Janáček - 8

Liszt - 17
Machaut - 8
Mahler - 18
Monteverdi - 37
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 22 (+5)
Scriabin - 15
Sibelius - 10
Stravinsky - 23
Wagner - 37 (+5)
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: ComposerOfAvantGarde on April 18, 2018, 05:03:43 PM


Bach (CPE) - 17
Beethoven - 10
Boulez - 22 (+5)
Cage - 13
Chopin - 10

Debussy - 17
Gesualdo - 15
Haydn - 14
Ives - 18
Janáček - 8

Liszt - 17
Machaut - 8
Mahler - 18
Monteverdi - 37
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 22
Scriabin - 15
Sibelius - 10
Stravinsky - 23
Wagner - 42 (+5)
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: mc ukrneal on April 18, 2018, 09:46:21 PM
Bach (CPE) - 17
Beethoven - 10
Boulez - 22
Cage - 13
Chopin - 10

Debussy - 17
Gesualdo - 15
Haydn - 14
Ives - 23 (+5)
Janáček - 8

Liszt - 17
Machaut - 8
Mahler - 18
Monteverdi - 42 (+5)
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 22
Scriabin - 15
Sibelius - 10
Stravinsky - 23
Wagner - 42
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Sammy on April 18, 2018, 10:02:02 PM
Bach (CPE) - 17
Beethoven - 10
Boulez - 22
Cage - 13
Chopin - 10

Debussy - 17
Gesualdo - 15
Haydn - 14
Ives - 23
Janáček - 8

Liszt - 17
Machaut - 8
Mahler - 23 (+5)
Monteverdi - 42
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 22
Scriabin - 20 (+5)
Sibelius - 10
Stravinsky - 23
Wagner - 42
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: GioCar on April 18, 2018, 11:54:19 PM
Bach (CPE) - 17
Beethoven - 15 (+5)
Boulez - 22
Cage - 13
Chopin - 10

Debussy - 17
Gesualdo - 15
Haydn - 14
Ives - 23
Janáček - 8

Liszt - 17
Machaut - 8
Mahler - 23
Monteverdi - 42
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 22
Scriabin - 20
Sibelius - 10
Stravinsky - 23
Wagner - 47 (+5)
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: San Antone on April 19, 2018, 12:03:04 AM
Bach (CPE) - 17
Beethoven - 15
Boulez - 22
Cage - 15 (+2)
Chopin - 10

Debussy - 21 (+4)
Gesualdo - 15
Haydn - 14
Ives - 23
Janáček - 8

Liszt - 21 (+4)
Machaut - 8
Mahler - 23
Monteverdi - 42
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 22
Scriabin - 20
Sibelius - 10
Stravinsky - 23
Wagner - 47
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Florestan on April 19, 2018, 03:08:57 AM
Bach (CPE) - 23 (+5)
Beethoven - 15
Boulez - 22
Cage - 15 (+2)
Chopin - 10

Debussy - 21
Gesualdo - 15
Haydn - 14
Ives - 23
Janáček - 8

Liszt - 26 (+5)
Machaut - 8
Mahler - 23
Monteverdi - 42
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 22
Scriabin - 20
Sibelius - 10
Stravinsky - 23
Wagner - 47
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Cato on April 19, 2018, 03:27:01 AM
Bach (CPE) - 23
Beethoven - 15
Boulez - 22
Cage - 15
Chopin - 10

Debussy - 21
Gesualdo - 20 (+5)
Haydn - 14
Ives - 23
Janáček - 8

Liszt - 26 
Machaut - 8
Mahler - 23
Monteverdi - 42
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 22
Scriabin - 25 (+5)
Sibelius - 10
Stravinsky - 23
Wagner - 47
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: André on April 19, 2018, 05:08:49 AM

Bach (CPE) - 23
Beethoven - 15
Boulez - 22
Cage - 15
Chopin - 10

Debussy - 21
Gesualdo - 20
Haydn - 19 (+5)
Ives - 23
Janáček - 8

Liszt - 28 (+2)
Machaut - 8
Mahler - 26 (+3)
Monteverdi - 42
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 22
Scriabin - 25
Sibelius - 10
Stravinsky - 23
Wagner - 47
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: ComposerOfAvantGarde on April 19, 2018, 06:07:11 AM
Bach (CPE) - 23
Beethoven - 15
Boulez - 27 (+5)
Cage - 15
Chopin - 10

Debussy - 21
Gesualdo - 20
Haydn - 19
Ives - 23
Janáček - 8

Liszt - 28
Machaut - 8
Mahler - 26
Monteverdi - 42
Mozart - 5

Schoenberg - 24 (+2)
Scriabin - 25
Sibelius - 10
Stravinsky - 23
Wagner - 50 (+3)
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Sammy on April 19, 2018, 06:51:51 AM
Florestan gave CPE Bach one too many points - should be 22 points.

This is the moment for the Half-Time Adjustment.  The 7 composers having 15 or fewer points are eliminated from the game.

Fresh Board:

Bach (CPE) - 22
Boulez - 27
Debussy - 21
Gesualdo - 20
Haydn - 19
Ives - 23

Liszt - 28
Mahler - 26
Monteverdi - 42
Schoenberg - 24
Scriabin - 25
Stravinsky - 23
Wagner - 50
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Crudblud on April 19, 2018, 06:58:26 AM
Bach (CPE) - 22
Boulez - 32 (+5)
Debussy - 21
Gesualdo - 20
Haydn - 19
Ives - 23

Liszt - 28
Mahler - 26
Monteverdi - 42
Schoenberg - 29 (+5)
Scriabin - 25
Stravinsky - 23
Wagner - 50
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: San Antone on April 19, 2018, 07:01:27 AM
Nice list.  Will we end up with five?
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Sammy on April 19, 2018, 07:04:51 AM
Quote from: San Antone on April 19, 2018, 07:01:27 AM
Nice list.  Will we end up with five?

When one of the line items reaches 100 points, I will announce the Top Five.
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Florestan on April 19, 2018, 10:45:57 AM
Quote from: Sammy on April 19, 2018, 06:51:51 AM
Florestan gave CPE Bach one too many points - should be 22 points.

You're right --- my head is spinning --- too many games, too many votes, too many calculations...  ;D
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: André on April 19, 2018, 11:47:44 AM
Quote from: Sammy on April 19, 2018, 06:51:51 AM
Florestan gave CPE Bach one too many points - should be 22 points.

This is the moment for the Half-Time Adjustment.  The 7 composers having 15 or fewer points are eliminated from the game.

Fresh Board:

Bach (CPE) - 22
Boulez - 27
Debussy - 21
Gesualdo - 20
Haydn - 19
Ives - 23

Liszt - 28
Mahler - 26
Monteverdi - 42
Schoenberg - 24
Scriabin - 25
Stravinsky - 23
Wagner - 50

Can I vote again today even if I voted before the half-time adjustment ? I'd rather ask than derail the computation  :)
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Sammy on April 19, 2018, 12:53:54 PM
Quote from: André on April 19, 2018, 11:47:44 AM
Can I vote again today even if I voted before the half-time adjustment ? I'd rather ask than derail the computation  :)

It's only one set of votes per day; half-time adjustments have nothing to do with voting frequency.
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: GioCar on April 19, 2018, 08:01:26 PM
Bach (CPE) - 22
Boulez - 32
Debussy - 23 (+2)
Gesualdo - 20
Haydn - 19
Ives - 23

Liszt - 28
Mahler - 26
Monteverdi - 44 (+2)
Schoenberg - 31 (+2)
Scriabin - 25
Stravinsky - 23
Wagner - 54 (+4)
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: mc ukrneal on April 19, 2018, 09:30:41 PM
Bach (CPE) - 22
Boulez - 32
Debussy - 23
Gesualdo - 20
Haydn - 19
Ives - 28 (+5)

Liszt - 28
Mahler - 26
Monteverdi - 49 (+5)
Schoenberg - 31
Scriabin - 25
Stravinsky - 23
Wagner - 54
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Crudblud on April 19, 2018, 10:09:04 PM
Bach (CPE) - 22
Boulez - 32
Debussy - 23
Gesualdo - 20
Haydn - 19
Ives - 33 (+5)

Liszt - 28
Mahler - 31 (+5)
Monteverdi - 49
Schoenberg - 31
Scriabin - 25
Stravinsky - 23
Wagner - 54
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Sammy on April 19, 2018, 11:09:32 PM
Bach (CPE) - 22
Boulez - 32
Debussy - 23
Gesualdo - 20
Haydn - 19
Ives - 33

Liszt - 28
Mahler - 36 (+5)
Monteverdi - 49
Schoenberg - 36 (+5)
Scriabin - 25
Stravinsky - 23
Wagner - 54
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Florestan on April 20, 2018, 12:21:20 AM
Bach (CPE) - 27 (+5)
Boulez - 32
Debussy - 23
Gesualdo - 20
Haydn - 19
Ives - 33

Liszt - 28
Mahler - 36
Monteverdi - 54 (+5)
Schoenberg - 36
Scriabin - 25
Stravinsky - 23
Wagner - 54
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: San Antone on April 20, 2018, 01:54:24 AM
Bach (CPE) - 27
Boulez - 32
Debussy - 28 (+5)
Gesualdo - 20
Haydn - 19
Ives - 33

Liszt - 33 (+5)
Mahler - 36
Monteverdi - 54
Schoenberg - 36
Scriabin - 25
Stravinsky - 23
Wagner - 54
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Cato on April 20, 2018, 03:34:41 AM
Bach (CPE) - 27
Boulez - 32
Debussy - 28
Gesualdo - 25 (+5)
Haydn - 19
Ives - 33

Liszt - 33
Mahler - 36
Monteverdi - 54
Schoenberg - 36
Scriabin - 30 (+5)
Stravinsky - 23
Wagner - 54
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Sergeant Rock on April 20, 2018, 03:47:40 AM

Bach (CPE) - 27
Boulez - 32
Debussy - 28
Gesualdo - 25
Haydn - 19
Ives - 33

Liszt - 33
Mahler - 36
Monteverdi - 54
Schoenberg - 41 (+5)
Scriabin - 30
Stravinsky - 23
Wagner - 59 (+5)
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: André on April 20, 2018, 04:41:34 AM

Bach (CPE) - 27
Boulez - 32
Debussy - 28
Gesualdo - 25
Haydn - 24 (+5)
Ives - 33

Liszt - 36 (+3)
Mahler - 38 (+2)
Monteverdi - 54
Schoenberg - 41
Scriabin - 30
Stravinsky - 23
Wagner - 59
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: ComposerOfAvantGarde on April 20, 2018, 06:04:46 AM
Bach (CPE) - 27
Boulez - 37 (+5)
Debussy - 28
Gesualdo - 25
Haydn - 24
Ives - 33

Liszt - 36
Mahler - 38
Monteverdi - 54
Schoenberg - 41
Scriabin - 30
Stravinsky - 23
Wagner - 64 (+5)
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Ken B on April 20, 2018, 06:24:54 AM

Bach (CPE) - 27
Boulez - 32
Debussy - 28
Gesualdo - 25
Haydn - 24
Ives - 33

Liszt - 36
Mahler - 38
Monteverdi - 59(+5)
Schoenberg - 41
Scriabin - 30
Stravinsky - 28(+5)
Wagner - 59
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: ComposerOfAvantGarde on April 20, 2018, 06:28:52 AM
Quote from: Ken B on April 20, 2018, 06:24:54 AM
Bach (CPE) - 27
Boulez - 37
Debussy - 28
Gesualdo - 25
Haydn - 24
Ives - 33

Liszt - 36
Mahler - 38
Monteverdi - 59(+5)
Schoenberg - 41
Scriabin - 30
Stravinsky - 28(+5)
Wagner - 64
fixed
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: mc ukrneal on April 20, 2018, 09:13:44 PM
Bach (CPE) - 27
Boulez - 37
Debussy - 28
Gesualdo - 25
Haydn - 24
Ives - 38 (+5)

Liszt - 36
Mahler - 38
Monteverdi - 64 (+5)
Schoenberg - 41
Scriabin - 30
Stravinsky - 28
Wagner - 64
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Crudblud on April 20, 2018, 09:35:45 PM
Bach (CPE) - 27
Boulez - 42 (+5)
Debussy - 28
Gesualdo - 25
Haydn - 24
Ives - 38

Liszt - 36
Mahler - 43 (+5)
Monteverdi - 64
Schoenberg - 41
Scriabin - 30
Stravinsky - 28
Wagner - 64
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Florestan on April 21, 2018, 12:15:50 AM
Bach (CPE) - 32 (+5)
Boulez - 42
Debussy - 28
Gesualdo - 25
Haydn - 24
Ives - 38

Liszt - 41 (+5)
Mahler - 43
Monteverdi - 64
Schoenberg - 41
Scriabin - 30
Stravinsky - 28
Wagner - 64
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Sammy on April 21, 2018, 12:19:23 AM
Bach (CPE) - 32
Boulez - 42
Debussy - 28
Gesualdo - 25
Haydn - 24
Ives - 38

Liszt - 41
Mahler - 43
Monteverdi - 64
Schoenberg - 46 (+5)
Scriabin - 30
Stravinsky - 28
Wagner - 69 (+5)
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: San Antone on April 21, 2018, 01:11:23 AM
Bach (CPE) - 32
Boulez - 42
Debussy - 33 (+5)
Gesualdo - 25
Haydn - 24
Ives - 38

Liszt - 46 (+5)
Mahler - 43
Monteverdi - 64
Schoenberg - 46
Scriabin - 30
Stravinsky - 28
Wagner - 69
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Cato on April 21, 2018, 01:46:58 AM
Bach (CPE) - 32
Boulez - 42
Debussy - 33
Gesualdo - 30 (+5)
Haydn - 24
Ives - 38

Liszt - 46
Mahler - 43
Monteverdi - 64
Schoenberg - 46
Scriabin - 35 (+5)
Stravinsky - 28
Wagner - 69
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: André on April 21, 2018, 04:06:01 AM

Bach (CPE) - 32
Boulez - 42
Debussy - 33
Gesualdo - 30
Haydn - 29 (+5)
Ives - 38

Liszt - 51 (+5)
Mahler - 43
Monteverdi - 64
Schoenberg - 46
Scriabin - 35
Stravinsky - 28
Wagner - 69
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: ComposerOfAvantGarde on April 21, 2018, 06:14:48 AM

Bach (CPE) - 32
Boulez - 42
Debussy - 33
Gesualdo - 30
Haydn - 29
Ives - 38

Liszt - 51
Mahler - 43
Monteverdi - 64
Schoenberg - 51 (+5)
Scriabin - 35
Stravinsky - 28
Wagner - 74 (+5)
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Ken B on April 21, 2018, 01:43:26 PM

Bach (CPE) - 32
Boulez - 42
Debussy - 33
Gesualdo - 30
Haydn - 29
Ives - 38

Liszt - 54(+3)
Mahler - 43
Monteverdi - 69(+5)
Schoenberg - 51
Scriabin - 35
Stravinsky - 30(+2)
Wagner - 74
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Crudblud on April 21, 2018, 08:42:20 PM
Bach (CPE) - 32
Boulez - 42
Debussy - 33
Gesualdo - 30
Haydn - 29
Ives - 43 (+5)

Liszt - 54
Mahler - 48 (+5)
Monteverdi - 69
Schoenberg - 51
Scriabin - 35
Stravinsky - 30
Wagner - 74
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: mc ukrneal on April 21, 2018, 09:36:46 PM
Bach (CPE) - 32
Boulez - 42
Debussy - 33
Gesualdo - 30
Haydn - 29
Ives - 48 (+5)

Liszt - 54
Mahler - 48
Monteverdi - 74 (+5)
Schoenberg - 51
Scriabin - 35
Stravinsky - 30
Wagner - 74
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Sammy on April 22, 2018, 12:52:14 AM
Bach (CPE) - 32
Boulez - 42
Debussy - 33
Gesualdo - 30
Haydn - 29
Ives - 48

Liszt - 54
Mahler - 48
Monteverdi - 74
Schoenberg - 56 (+5)
Scriabin - 35
Stravinsky - 30
Wagner - 79 (+5)
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: GioCar on April 22, 2018, 12:57:07 AM
Bach (CPE) - 32
Boulez - 42
Debussy - 33
Gesualdo - 30
Haydn - 29
Ives - 48

Liszt - 54
Mahler - 48
Monteverdi - 79 (+5)
Schoenberg - 56
Scriabin - 35
Stravinsky - 30
Wagner - 84 (+5)
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Cato on April 22, 2018, 03:27:39 AM

Bach (CPE) - 32
Boulez - 42
Debussy - 33
Gesualdo - 35 (+5)
Haydn - 29
Ives - 48

Liszt - 54
Mahler - 48
Monteverdi - 79
Schoenberg - 56
Scriabin - 40 (+5)
Stravinsky - 30
Wagner - 84
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: ComposerOfAvantGarde on April 22, 2018, 05:32:17 AM
Bach (CPE) - 32
Boulez - 47 (+5)
Debussy - 33
Gesualdo - 35
Haydn - 29
Ives - 48

Liszt - 54
Mahler - 48
Monteverdi - 79
Schoenberg - 56
Scriabin - 40
Stravinsky - 30
Wagner - 89 (+5)
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Ken B on April 22, 2018, 05:41:29 AM

Bach (CPE) - 32
Boulez - 47 (+5)
Debussy - 33
Gesualdo - 35
Haydn - 29
Ives - 48

Liszt - 54
Mahler - 48
Monteverdi - 84(+5)
Schoenberg - 57(+1)
Scriabin - 40
Stravinsky - 33(+3)
Wagner - 90(+1)
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Sergeant Rock on April 22, 2018, 06:07:32 AM
Bach (CPE) - 32
Boulez - 47
Debussy - 33
Gesualdo - 35
Haydn - 29
Ives - 48

Liszt - 54
Mahler - 48
Monteverdi - 84
Schoenberg - 62 (+5)
Scriabin - 40
Stravinsky - 33
Wagner - 95 (+5)
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: San Antone on April 22, 2018, 06:23:14 AM
Bach (CPE) - 32
Boulez - 47
Debussy - 33
Gesualdo - 35
Haydn - 29
Ives - 48

Liszt - 59 (+5)
Mahler - 48
Monteverdi - 84
Schoenberg - 62
Scriabin - 40
Stravinsky - 33
Wagner - 100 (+5)
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Crudblud on April 22, 2018, 07:10:48 AM
Well, this one turned out more interesting than the string quartet game is shaping up to be.
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Ken B on April 22, 2018, 07:17:58 AM
Quote from: Crudblud on April 22, 2018, 07:10:48 AM
Well, this one turned out more interesting than the string quartet game is shaping up to be.
Really? Why is that? I think most informed listeners looking at nominees would pick Wagner, Monteverdi, Liszt and Schoenberg as the obvious choices.
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Crudblud on April 22, 2018, 07:52:30 AM
Quote from: Ken B on April 22, 2018, 07:17:58 AM
Really? Why is that? I think most informed listeners looking at nominees would pick Wagner, Monteverdi, Liszt and Schoenberg as the obvious choices.
Take those four and the tie between Mahler and Ives, you've got yourself quite a range of unique styles, albeit not much in terms of different periods. The finalists in general make quite an exciting list, though I would rather have seen Beethoven in there than Scriabin. As for why I find it more interesting than the string quartets game so far, I already posted about that in the round two thread.
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Sammy on April 22, 2018, 08:45:14 AM
Our game is over with Richard Wagner voted GMG's Grand Innovator!!

The Top Five Innovators (actually six):

1.  Wagner
2.  Monteverdi
3.  Schoenberg
4.  Liszt
5.  Ives
6.  Mahler

Thanks for voting, and I hope that at least one of your favored entries did well in this final round.
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: André on April 22, 2018, 11:28:18 AM
At various points in this round I supported 4 of the finalists. Can't complain  :).
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Sergeant Rock on April 22, 2018, 11:46:04 AM
Four of the finalists (Mahler, Wagner, Ives and Arnie) have been favorites of mine for over a half century. So yes, I'm pleased with the results. (Although, truthfully,  I think Debussy, Haydn and Stravinsky more innovative than Mahler).

Sarge
Title: Re: Innovative Composer Game (Final Round)
Post by: Cato on April 24, 2018, 03:26:16 AM
Quote from: Sergeant Rock on April 22, 2018, 11:46:04 AM
Four of the finalists (Mahler, Wagner, Ives and Arnie) have been favorites of mine for over a half century. So yes, I'm pleased with the results. (Although, truthfully,  I think Debussy, Haydn and Stravinsky more innovative than Mahler).

Sarge

Amen!  0:)

And...

Scriabin M.I.A.
Text only | Text with Images