Beethoven's Piano Sonatas

[Wanderer]

Is Gulda (amadeo) better than Gulda live on Orfeo?

Yes.

[Mandryka]

I have another Sokolov Hammerklavier that I rate very highly. It's from 1975 and the slow movement is just so superbly played, but then again so is the rest of the sonata. It is my favourite version. Hasanyone else heard it and can compare it to this 2012 rendition?

But why din't you just listen to the 2012 yourself?

[Mandryka]

Yes.

Well, that's saved me a few quid.

[NJ Joe]

I am 100% for that Gulda set, Joe; it totally knocked me out when I got it not very long ago.  FYI maybe you would dig Gulda's Mozart sonatas as well and maybe for similar reasons, if your response is like mine; I just got the COMPLETE MOZART TAPES set (the one that collected the smaller Vol. 1 and Vol. 2 sets), and even though the recorded sound is iffy, his playing is marvelous.  I am glad I have alternatives for these pieces, but I must say that Gulda ignites them.  Sorry for the off-topic digression, everyone.

I appreciate your comments, as I've been reading up on Gulda and learning that he was thought highly of as a Mozart interpreter. I most definitely plan on exploring his Mozart, as well as his WTC Book II (I have Book I and love it).

[Brian]

Is this the beginning of a new cycle?

[Todd]

Is this the beginning of a new cycle?

Sure looks that way.  Now I'm left wondering, should I buy?

[George]

Sure looks that way.  Now I'm left wondering, should I buy?

With a name like James Brawn, how can you go wrong?

[Todd]

With a name like James Brawn, how can you go wrong?

What if his playing is characterized by delicate legato?  (Not that there's anything wrong with that.)  No, I know I will buy.  Do I buy disc by disc, or wait a few years and buy all at once?

[George]

What if his playing is characterized by delicate legato?  (Not that there's anything wrong with that.)  No, I know I will buy.  Do I buy disc by disc, or wait a few years and buy all at once?

I say wait.

[Todd]

I say wait.

I'm inclined to agree, unless I start reading that his cycle is The Bomb.

[Brian]

I'm inclined to agree, unless I start reading that his cycle is The Bomb.

You can at least wait long enough to find out how long a delay there will be between issues, I s'pose.

MusicWeb offered the chance to review Yundi (Li)'s new 8/14/23, but I listened to clips and it sounded like a snooze. I don't like having to write reviews when the words that come to mind are "average, plain, same."

[Todd]

You can at least wait long enough to find out how long a delay there will be between issues, I s'pose.

I wouldn't be one bit surprised if the whole thing is slated to be done in about 2020.

[jlaurson]

... when the words that come to mind are "average, plain, same."

That's an adequate review of it, right there. 

Add "perfectly nice" to the mix, that wonderfully cliched (sometimes very useful) phrase of damnation with faint praise... because it's that, too. Listened to it a few times, then twice more out of courtesy, then it went onto the thanksbutnothanks pile.

[kishnevi]

That's an adequate review of it, right there. 

Add "perfectly nice" to the mix, that wonderfully cliched (sometimes very useful) phrase of damnation with faint praise... because it's that, too. Listened to it a few times, then twice more out of courtesy, then it went onto the thanksbutnothanks pile.

I have both the Yundi CD and Jonathan Biss's second volume en route to me from Arkivmusic; I expect a contrast.  But even as I ordered it, I expected Yundi's performance to fit into the "perfectly nice" category (or what I often think of as "a safe choice to suggest to someone who has had no real exposure to [composer/music genre/specific genre by a specific composer] ) .

[George]

That's an adequate review of it, right there. 

Add "perfectly nice" to the mix, that wonderfully cliched (sometimes very useful) phrase of damnation with faint praise... because it's that, too. Listened to it a few times, then twice more out of courtesy, then it went onto the thanksbutnothanks pile.

Nice is not a word I ever want to see in a Beethoven review. I'd run for the hills.

[Fred]

BEen listening to Byron Janis (op21, 17', 109) in the new box set.  What a stunning pianist he was in prime.  Terrible that he didn't record more beethoven.

[Wakefield]

I have both the Yundi CD and Jonathan Biss's second volume en route to me from Arkivmusic; I expect a contrast.  But even as I ordered it, I expected Yundi's performance to fit into the "perfectly nice" category (or what I often think of as "a safe choice to suggest to someone who has had no real exposure to [composer/music genre/specific genre by a specific composer] ) .

It's a great practical lesson about how to be condescending in music. 

[George]

BEen listening to Byron Janis (op21, 17', 109) in the new box set.  What a stunning pianist he was in prime.  Terrible that he didn't record more beethoven.

I agree.

[Mandryka]

Jonathan Biss has so far impressed me the most of all the newer cycles in progress; his playing of Beethoven is almost perfect for my taste.

Have you read his book, Beethoven's Shadow?

[Mandryka]

No, I haven't.  What is it like?

Oh . . . I was hoping you'd tell me.